All 2G accused move court for having TRAI report on its record

Seeking direction to the investigating agency to file the report, which has said there was no loss to the exchequer in allocation of 2G spectrum

PTI | September 6, 2011



A Delhi court on Tuesday sought CBI's stand on a plea by all 17 accused in the 2G spectrum case, including former telecom minister A Raja and DMK MP Kanimozhi, for making the TRAI report a part of the court's records.

All the accused, including the three telecom firms and their promoters, proprietors and top executives, moved the court of special CBI (Central Bureau of Investigation) judge O P Saini seeking direction to the investigating agency to file the TRAI (Telecom Regulatory Authority of India) report, which has said there was no loss to the exchequer in allocation of 2G spectrum.

The report has also recommended against both auctioning of radio waves and revising entry fee for telecom firms.

The Comptroller and Auditor General had assessed a "presumptive loss" of Rs 1.76 lakh crore to the state exchequer, while the CBI, during its probe into the 2G scam, had pegged the loss at Rs 30,9884 crore.

Seeking its stand on the scam accused plea, Special Judge Saini issued notice to the CBI and fixed September 9 for arguments on their plea.

Appearing for Raja, senior counsel Ramesh Gupta sought the court's direction to the CBI to bring the latest TRAI report on court's record.

So did Swan telecom promoter Shahid Usman Balwa's counsel Vijay Aggarwal. In an application, he told the court, "The CBI has no scientific or technical expertise to determine the loss. In fact, CBI has itself made an admission in the charge sheet that the TRAI report is awaited for calculating the quantum of loss."

Aggarwal said the basic question for the court is to determine whether there is any loss to the exchequer and if TRAI recommended that the spectrum be auctioned.

"Thus for deciding the same question, the TRAI report is essentially required as the same is a vital document and the same is relied even by the CBI in the charge sheet by stating it to be awaited," Aggarwal said, adding "it is an essential document and now in the possession of the CBI".

Aggarwal also sought directions to the CBI to call for the Union Law Ministry report to the Department of Telecom on applicability of clause 8 of Unified Access Service Licence (UASL) guidelines, which, as per the report, purportedly applies only to companies holding a telecom licence and not to the applicants.

The law ministry report has also purportedly clarified the definition of term 'associate'.

Balwa's counsel had earlier argued before the court that his company Swan Telecom as an applicant for the 2G licence was not covered by the clause 8 of the UASL guidelines, which says no single company, either directly or through its associates, should have substantial equity holding in more than one licence company in the same service area for the same service.

He had said the said clause was applicable only to the existing licencee.

Reliance Telecom, which also moved an application for having TRAI report on court's record, had contended that Reliance ADAG firm did not violate guidelines as its equities were below 10 per cent in the Shahid Balwa-promoted firm and that what is to be seen is whether Clause 8 of UASL guidelines was violated or not on the date of grant of licence and not on the date of application.

Comments

 

Other News

Mumbai’s missing affordable homes

Mumbai’s real estate market keeps growing, yet homeownership remains out of reach for much of its population. Three experts – urban researcher Hussain Indorewala, urban planner Vidyadhar Phatak and developer Kamlesh Thakur of NAREDCO Maharashtra, agree that simply constructing more apartments

Rubio denies US foreknowledge of Starlink restrictions in Ukraine

US secretary of state Marco Rubio has said he was unfamiliar with the Wall Street Journal report suggesting Elon Musk had decided to throttle Starlink services in Ukraine, but rejected claims that Washington had ordered the restrictions to pressure Kyiv.   “There was no

Can AI change India’s breast cancer story?

Breast cancer has become a public-health challenge in India. The greatest opportunity is to find cancers earlier. Artificial intelligence (AI) is opening a new era in breast cancer detection. AI systems can analyse mammograms and other breast-imaging studies, identify subtle abnormalities and assist radi

Farm stability in the time of climate change

Indian agriculture is experiencing significant climate volatility, while the world economy seems to be in a highly volatile situation. Economic indices from various countries show that they need to recalibrate their strategies to withstand economic headwinds. In such a challenging situation, a country li

El Niño threatens India’s Rabi crops

India’s southwest monsoon ended with a 13% rainfall deficit in 2026, its weakest performance in a decade, raising concerns over agricultural production, water security and the upcoming rabi season. With El Niño expected to persist into early 2027, experts warn that declining soil moisture, dep

Regulating the data advantage: India’s new e-Commerce framework

For over a decade, India’s e-commerce story has rested on a simple premise: platforms connect buyers and sellers, while data fuels efficiency, personalisation, and scale. However, as the market matured, its structure has revealed a growing imbalance. E-commerce platforms, especially marketplace ent

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter