Ex-CVC Thomas withdraws plea from HC against his sacking

Plea withdrawn after justice said that hierarchy of the judiciary cannot be disturbed

PTI | July 19, 2011



Former CVC P J Thomas on Tuesday withdrew from the Delhi high court his plea for direction to the Rashtrapati Bhawan to decide his representation against the supreme court order sacking him.

"I seek to withdraw my petition," Wills Mathews, the counsel for Thomas told justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, seeking to withdraw his plea from the court.

Mathews withdrew the plea after justice Endlaw remarked, "You cannot disturb the hierarchy of the judiciary and hence you please go to the same court."

During the hearing, the counsel for Thomas tried to clarify the position saying he did not want to challenge the supreme court order before the high court.

"My prayer is limited to issuance of a direction to the department of personnel and training which has not decided my representation to the president seeking constitution of a five judge bench to decide afresh my removal from the post," Mathews said.

Justice Endlaw was not impressed with the argument and he told the advocate that the legal remedy is to approach the supreme court itself. This prompted Thomas to withdraw his plea.

Initiating the arguments, the counsel for Thomas said his plea seeking disposal of his representation before the appointment of his successor, Pradeep Kumar, has now become infructuous.

Earlier on July 14, the day the new CVC took oath, the high court had refused to grant urgent hearing to Thomas' plea that his appeal, pending with the president against his sacking, be decided before his successor Pradeep Kumar assumes charge.

"It is quite difficult to hear your petition at the eleventh hour," a division bench of justices Vikramjit Sen and Sindharth Mridul had said referring to the oath taking ceremony of the new CVC scheduled at 11 am that day.

Thomas had pleaded for a direction to president Pratibha Devisingh Patil not to issue any warrant of appointment as CVC to defence secretary Kumar without first deciding his representation to her against the judgement of the supreme court.

The apex court had on March 3 quashed the appointment of Thomas as CVC as a charge sheet was pending against him in a corruption case in Kerala. Thomas was appointed as CVC in September 2010.

Thomas had sought a direction to the ministry of personnel and public grievances that his representation against the supreme court verdict be decided within three weeks.

In his representation to the president, Thomas had sought invoking of Article 143 of the Constitution which empowers the president to get a five-member bench constituted to review the supreme court's order quashing his appointment.

Thomas had cited reasons for non-filing a review plea before the supreme court saying the decision by its three judge bench lacked jurisdiction.

Comments

 

Other News

Master sculptor recalls the making of the Shankaracharya statue

The Golden Chisel: The Story Behind the Making of Ram Lalla  By Seethalakshmi S. and Rahul Nandan Rupa Publications, 168 pages, Rs 395  

Mumbai’s missing affordable homes

Mumbai’s real estate market keeps growing, yet homeownership remains out of reach for much of its population. Three experts – urban researcher Hussain Indorewala, urban planner Vidyadhar Phatak and developer Kamlesh Thakur of NAREDCO Maharashtra, agree that simply constructing more apartments

Rubio denies US foreknowledge of Starlink restrictions in Ukraine

US secretary of state Marco Rubio has said he was unfamiliar with the Wall Street Journal report suggesting Elon Musk had decided to throttle Starlink services in Ukraine, but rejected claims that Washington had ordered the restrictions to pressure Kyiv.   “There was no

Can AI change India’s breast cancer story?

Breast cancer has become a public-health challenge in India. The greatest opportunity is to find cancers earlier. Artificial intelligence (AI) is opening a new era in breast cancer detection. AI systems can analyse mammograms and other breast-imaging studies, identify subtle abnormalities and assist radi

Farm stability in the time of climate change

Indian agriculture is experiencing significant climate volatility, while the world economy seems to be in a highly volatile situation. Economic indices from various countries show that they need to recalibrate their strategies to withstand economic headwinds. In such a challenging situation, a country li

El Niño threatens India’s Rabi crops

India’s southwest monsoon ended with a 13% rainfall deficit in 2026, its weakest performance in a decade, raising concerns over agricultural production, water security and the upcoming rabi season. With El Niño expected to persist into early 2027, experts warn that declining soil moisture, dep

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter