No SC order in petition against Sibal

All telecom irregularities cannot be linked to 2G: SC

PTI | July 11, 2011



The supreme court today refrained from passing any order on a PIL filed against telecom minister Kapil Sibal accusing him of reducing a penalty amount favouring Anil Ambani-headed RCOM, saying persons aggrieved can avail remedy under the law.

"No order is required," a bench comprising justices G S Singhvi and A K Ganguly said while taking on file the affidavit filed by Centre for Public Interest Litigation (CPIL) accusing Sibal of favouring RCOM by reducing the penalty from Rs 650 crore to five crore for alleged violations in the Unified Access Service Licence (UASL) agreement.

"If there is any irregularity allegedly connected whatsoever with telecom, it cannot be linked to the 2G," the bench said.

The bench made the remarks after senior advocate Rohinton Nariman, who appeared for the government in place of solicitor general Gopal Subramanium, replied to a question whether the matter in hand was related to 2G.

"Not at all," replied Nariman.

The bench clarified "persons aggrieved will be entitled to avail remedy in accordance with the law."

During the hearing when advocate Prashant Bhushan appearing for CPIL was pressing for the matter to be investigated as Sibal had taken a unilaterally and final decision.

The bench said "it is open to CBI for investigation. I am not saying anything" adding, "the minister's decision may be right or may be wrong".

The affidavit had alleged that "Sibal abused his position as minister to overrule the unanimous view taken by senior DoT officials, including the telecom secretary, to benefit a private operator by closing the issue with only a penalty of Rs 5 crore.

“This abuse of authority by him to benefit Anil Ambani-controlled Reliance Infocomm needs a thorough investigation by the CBI," the application said.

However, Sibal rejected the allegations saying he had not favoured anyone and that the penalty imposed was as per the provisions of the agreement between Universal Service Obligation Fund (USOF) and RCOM.

He described the Bhushan's affidavit as the "worst case of forum shopping" and accused him of levelling "malicious and defamatory" charges.
 

Comments

 

Other News

How Rafi, Raj Kapoor helped pave the way for a great uranium deal

There`s a certain moment in diplomacy that`s too personal to be captured in a communiqué, too small to make the front page, but more revealing than the front page. This week, prime minister Narendra Modi reached Tashkent and, amid the pomp of state visits, managed to evoke the old Bollywood tunes

Distinguishing Fish 1 and Fish 2: The pragmatism behind India’s WTO ratification

 India became the 123rd WTO member to ratify the multilateral Agreement on Fisheries subsidies (AoFS) when it deposited the Instrument of Acceptance for Phase 1 on July 20, 2026. The ratification is restricted to disciplining Illegal, Unreported and Unregulated fishing (IUU), protection for overfished

The 7% growth problem: Why the next 7% will be harder

India has become accustomed to hearing the 7% growth number. It is now less a milestone than an expectation. Yet the paradox is becoming clearer: maintaining 7% growth may be considerably harder than achieving it once. India’s real GDP grew 7.7% in FY2025–26, following growth of 6.5% in FY202

The Constitution cannot be altered: Justice Abhay Oka

Justice Abhay Oka, who retired from the Supreme Court in May 2025, has said that the Constitution of India cannot be altered. Explaining the landmark Kesavananda Bharati judgment (1973) on the basic structure of the Constitution, he said, “This is one judgment that has saved democracy in India.&rdq

How the flora and fauna evolved in the Indian subcontinent

Mammals of India  By A.J.T. Johnsingh and P.O. Nameer HarperCollins India in association with Bombay Natural History Society  

India`s renewable race is moving beyond megawatts

When Shell bought Sprng Energy in 2022, India`s renewable energy market appeared to offer precisely what global energy majors were seeking: scale, growth and a place in one of the world`s largest energy transitions. Four years later, Shell is selling the same business to Aditya Birla Group for an enterpris

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter