Rahul whitewashes remarks, brings LeT on a par with Hindu radicals

Cong releases statement on his behalf, says will wait for facts for commenting as a party

PTI | December 17, 2010


Congress leader Rahul Gandhi
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi

Coming under attack after his reported statement that "radicalised Hindu groups" posed a bigger threat than outfits like Lashkar-e-Taiba, Rahul Gandhi today diluted his comments saying that terrorism and communalism of all types are a threat to India.

"Rahul Gandhi's view is that terrorism and communalism of all types are a threat to India. We need to remain vigilant against acts of terrorism of all kinds no matter who commits them," AICC General Secretary Janardan Dwivedi said in a release issued on his behalf.

The statement came hours after Congress grappled with the issue of the WikiLeaks cable which claimed that Rahul Gandhi had told US Ambassador Timothy Roemer that growth of "radicalised Hindu groups" which create religious tensions in India could pose a bigger threat to the country than activities of groups like Lashkar-e-Taiba.

This in a way is the first acknowledgement from the Congress that Gandhi had indeed talked to Roemer on the issue.

The initial reaction of the Congress on the issue was one of dilemma with party spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi saying, "We will respond to it after verifying the facts.

There is no reason to react in an excited manner. The issue should first be looked into and verified".

Dwivedi, who is also AICC media department chairman, had first suspected a conspiracy behind the release of WikiLeaks cable saying, "Let us verify the truth. May be there is some conspiracy behind the pattern with which this all is being done."

However, a clarification came quickly with the media department in-charge confining his remarks to "let us verify the truth".

Asked what is there to doubt in the issue, the Singhvi remarked, "I am not questioning anything and I am questioning everything".

To a query on whether what he says indicates that the party is distancing itself from Rahul Gandhi's remarks, Singhvi said, "The question does not arise.It is your interpretation."

According to a secret US diplomatic cable from New Delhi released by WikiLeaks, at a luncheon hosted by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh at his residence in July 2009, the Congress General Secretary was asked by the US ambassador about LeT's activities in the region and immediate threat to India.

"Gandhi said there was evidence of some support for the group among certain elements in India's indigenous Muslim community," the cable notes.

"However, Gandhi warned, the bigger threat may be the growth of radicalised Hindu groups, which create religious tensions and political confrontations with the Muslim community," it says.

Related reports:

Saffron terror bigger threat than Lashkar: Rahul Gandhi to US

Congress leader Rahul Gandhi allegedly told US Ambassador to India Timothy Roemer that growth of "Radicalised Hindu groups" posed a bigger threat to the country than militant groups like Lashkar-e-Toiba (LeT), according to WikiLeaks, a leaked American diplomatic cable.

Rahul during a conversation with the envoy at a luncheon hosted by prime minister Manmohan Singh at his residence in July 2009 in honour of visiting secretary of state Hillary Clinton also referred to the tensions created by some of the more polarising figures in the BJP such as Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi, the cable said.

According to a secret US diplomatic cable from New Delhi released by WikiLeaks, Rahul shared his views with Roemer on a range of political topics, social challenges, and electoral issues for the Congress party in the next five years.

"Responding to the ambassador's query about LeT activities in the region and immediate threat to India, Gandhi said there was evidence of some support for the group among certain elements in India's indigenous muslim community," the cable notes, "However, Gandhi warned, the bigger threat may be the growth of radicalised Hindu groups, which create religious tensions and political confrontations with the muslim community."

The cable dated August 3, 2009 which described Roemer's luncheon encounter with Gandhi on July 20, 2009, said Gandhi was referring to the tensions created by some of the more polarising figures in the BJP such as Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi.

"The risk of a 'home-grown' extremist front, reacting to terror attacks coming from Pakistan or from Islamist groups in India, was a growing concern and one that demanded constant attention," it said.

The cable signed off by Roemer says that Gandhi, who was seated next to the ambassador, was forthright in describing the challenges faced by the Congress party and the UPA government in the months ahead.

Meanwhile, the Congress suspects a conspiracy behind the release of these WikiLeaks cable. "Let us verify the truth. May be there is some conspiracy behind the pattern with which this all is being done," party general secretary Janardan Diwedi said on Friday.

When contacted in New Delhi, the US embassy offered no comments on the WikiLeaks contents. The US, which has accused WikiLeaks of stealing its secret cables, has refused to either deny or confirm the authenticity of these cables.

Slamming Rahul, BJP said Congress wants to create a communal strife so that they can have a vote harvest in the coming elections.

"They (Congress) are feeling let down by the corruption scandals and price rise so they are afraid of losing elections. This is their old trick," BJP spokesperson Tarun Vijay said.

According to the cable, Roemer said, "Over the past four years, he (Rahul) was an elusive contact, but he could be interested in reaching out to the US, given a thoughtful, politically sensitive and strategic approach on our part".

Roemer spoke about the need to reach out to the young leaders of the country. "We will seek other opportunities to engage with him and with other promising young members of the new generation of parliamentarians," he was quoted as having said. "Gandhi mentioned that in the recent election 60 members of the new parliament were 45 or younger," according to the cable.

"In a system long viewed as relatively static, the influx of new faces and the rising profile of young leaders like Rahul Gandhi provides us an opening to expand the constituency in support of the strategic partnership with a long term horizon," Roemer said.

This particular cable is one of about 3,038 US diplomatic cables sent from Delhi and leaked by the whistle-blower website. WikiLeaks is releasing a quarter million secret US documents and 5,087 records amongst these refer to India.

''Rahul becoming increasingly sure-footed''

Another cable from the US embassy in New Delhi in February this year cited Rahul's move to take on Shiv Sena's "xenophobic agenda," and said the young Congress leader appears to be becoming increasingly sure-footed in his political instincts.

This secret cable is dated February 22, 2010 and is a diary of the political events in the country from January 30 to February 19.

The document said Gandhi's blunt words against the "Maharashtra chauvinist" party, followed by his visit to Mumbai that came with a local train ride was a public relations bonanza for him.

"Rahul Gandhi's Mumbai visit and his skirmishing with the Maharashtra chauvinist Shiv Sena party shows he is becoming increasingly sure-footed in his political instincts," said the cable.

"He (Gandhi) first hurled some blunt words at the Thackerays and Shiv Sena's xenophobic agenda. These were widely and sympathetically reported around the country. He then took it a step further when the Shiv Sena issued 'Keep off Maharashtra' threats by going to the Thackerays' home ground of Mumbai, where he continued to take shots at them," the cable says referring to the political events of those days.

The cable added Rahul topped it off by showing the common touch when he made a last minute change in his itinerary to travel across town in a second-class train compartment. The document noted that Shiv Sena supremo Bal Thackeray responded by launching an attack on Rahul Gandhi's "Italian mummy," referring to UPA chief Sonia Gandhi.

In late 2007, US diplomats had described Gandhi as "widely viewed as an empty suit and will have to prove wrong those who dismiss him as a lightweight".

"To do so he will have to demonstrate determination, depth, savvy and stamina," it said.

"He will need to get his hands dirty in the untidy and ruthless business that is Indian politics," a diplomat reportedly said in a cable entitled 'The son also rises: Rahul Gandhi takes another step towards top job'.

Other US cables talk of Gandhi's political inexperience and repeated gaffes.

They also repeat cutting criticism from political analysts and journalists.

However, the cables reportedly reveal that as Gandhi warmed to the US, the US warmed to him.

In a meeting with another American official last summer, he explained his strategy of targeting rural populations and small towns, impressing his interlocutor.

"(Gandhi) came off as a practiced politician who knew how to get his message across, was precise and articulate and demonstrated a mastery that belied the image some have of (him) as a dilettante," the official said.

In November last year, after a meeting with the US ambassador, a cable to Washington described Gandhi as "an elusive contact in the past" but now "clearly interested in reaching out to the USG (United States government)".

A cable from February this year describes him as "increasingly sure-footed".

For Roemer, writing after the lunch during which Gandhi had commented on extremism, "the rising profile of young leaders like Rahul Gandhi provides (the USA with) an opening to expand the constituency in support of the strategic partnership with a long term horizon".

Rahul has given Pak's terror popaganda leverage: BJP

Cong stands by Rahul gandhi's statements, blames BJP for politicising the issue

Rahul Gandhi was today at the centre of a political storm in the wake of his controversial remarks that Hindu extremists posed a bigger threat than terror outfits like Lashkar-e-Taiba, with the BJP and the RSS accusing him of giving "big leverage" to propaganda of terror groups in Pakistan.

Caught on the backfoot after WikiLeaks made public a a secret communication to Washington by US Ambassador to India Timothy Roemer on his conversation with Rahul, Congress tried some damage control exercise.

"Rahul Gandhi's view is that terrorism and communalism of all types are a threat to India. We need to remain vigilant against acts of terrorism of all kinds no matter who commits them," AICC General Secretary Janardan Dwivedi said in a release issued on his behalf.

The statement came hours after Congress grappled with the issue of the WikiLeaks cable which said Rahul had told Roemer that growth of "radicalised Hindu groups" which create religious tensions in India posed a bigger threat to the country than activities of groups like LeT.

This in a way is the first acknowledgement from the Congress that Gandhi had indeed talked to Roemer on the issue.

The initial reaction of the Congress on the issue was one of dilemma with party spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi saying, "We will respond to it after verifying the facts.

There is no reason to react in an excited manner. The issue should first be looked into and verified".

Dwivedi, who is also AICC media department chairman, had first suspected a conspiracy angle behind the release of WikiLeaks cable saying, "Let us verify the truth. May be there is some conspiracy behind the pattern with which this all is being done."

All this did not cut ice with the BJP with its spokesperson Ravishankar Prasad saying, "In one stroke, Rahul Gandhi has sought to give a big leverage to the propaganda of all terror groups operating from Pakistan and certain segments of the Pakistan establishment."

Describing Rahul's comments as "irresponsible", he said, "If he sees a fringe radical Hindu group as the biggest threat in spite of so many terrorist attacks including 26/11 in which involvement of Pakistani groups is confirmed, then it only underscores how ignorant he is about India and its problems."

The RSS too slammed Rahul for his "shocking" remarks against Hindu groups, saying there was a "race" in the senior Congress leadership to project Hindus as terrorists.

According to the cable from New Delhi, at a luncheon hosted by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh at his residence in July 2009, the Congress General Secretary was asked by the US Ambassador about LeT's activities in the region and immediate threat to India

"Rahul Gandhi said there was evidence of some support for the group among certain elements in India's indigenous Muslim community," the cable notes.

"However, Gandhi warned, the bigger threat may be the growth of radicalised Hindu groups, which create religious tensions and political confrontations with the Muslim community," it says.

Prasad said the statement "underscores how little Rahul knows about India. The PM has publicly acknowledged that Maoism and terrorist threat from across the border are the biggest challenges before India and Rahul Gandhi says certain lunatic, marginalised Hindu radical groups are the biggest threat."

BJP leader Prakash Javadekar said Rahul's remarks shows "crass communalism and jaundiced world view".

Bringing Rahul under the line of fire, senior RSS leader Ram Madhav said, "It is shocking that there is a race in the senior Congress leadership to indirectly or directly support jehadi terror and to project Hindus as terrorists in this country, that too in gross violation of established diplomatic norms and procedures."

"Going to a foreign ambassador and talking with him about India's international issues is most shocking. It only betrays utter lack of knowledge of Indian reality as well as lack of knowledge of government diplomatic practices in a person who aspires to be whatever in this country tomorrow," Madhav said.

He alleged that Rahul was making "wild charges" against Hindus.

WikiLeaks has exposed how Congress has no qualms in using religion and caste and exploiting these sentiments for electoral gains, he said.

"There is no secret now about Congress' politics of religion," he said.

The RSS leader was referring to Roemer's predecessor David Mulford's remarks, who had said that Congress planned to polarise the electorate on religious and caste lines to gain votes, according to Wikileaks.

Congress spokesman Manish Tewari hit back at the BJP for targeting Rahul, saying those who have not shed a drop of blood to fight terrorism were attacking a family which has sacrificed for the cause of the unity and integrity of the country.

Alleging that it has always been the BJP's habit of communalising and politicising each issue, he said that it has been the Congress belief that terrorism has no religion.

"The views of Rahul Gandhi are those of the Congress", said Tewari when asked whether the party "accepted" the statements made by Gandhi to the US ambassador.

Comments

 

Other News

Testing the teachers, moving the goalposts

A teacher was appointed in 1999, before the Right to Education (RTE) Act came into force, and appointed under the rules that existed at that time. She gave the necessary test, passed it, passed the interview, and was appointed. Over the next 26 years, she taught thousands of children, faced transfer orde

`Focus on infra, reforms, digital connectivity has created strong foundation for growth`

In a step towards the operationalisation of the Bharat Audyogik Vikas Yojana (BHAVYA), union minister of commerce & industry Piyush Goyal launched the BHAVYA Portal on Monday in New Delhi.   Addressing the gathering, Goyal said that the BHAVYA scheme will adopt a competit

Govt, RBI announce major reforms to attract FPI

The finance ministry on Friday announced a series of measures aimed at enhancing the ease of investment for individual Persons Resident Outside India (PROIs) and Foreign Portfolio Investors (FPIs), and to attract stable long-term foreign capital flows.   Building on the recent in

Lessons in climate adaption from world’s largest inhabited river island

Majuli Island, perched between the Brahmaputra River to the south and east, the Subansiri River to the west, and a branch of the Brahmaputra to the north, has been severely affected by recurrent flooding and intense riverbank erosion. Despite its global importance in acquiring UNESCO tentative status for

Careless whispers and the impossible trinity

Time can never mend, the careless whispers of …    As the RBI marches ahead, for the upcoming monetary policy meeting this June, whispers from the corridors echo around several policy options to defend the rupee – by deploying forex reserves, raising in

Bullet Train Project: Third mountain tunnel breakthrough achieved

A major engineering milestone has been achieved in the Mumbai–Ahmedabad Bullet Train Project with the successful breakthrough of the third mountain tunnel (MT-07) at Ambesari village in Dahanu Taluka of Palghar district, Maharashtra.   With this achievement, three mountain





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter