Plunging rupee and coal dependence

Coal contributes significantly to CAD and the weakening rupee through large coal imports and coal-related investments abroad. The only way out is to minimise India’s coal dependence

arundhati-muthu

Arundhati Muthu | September 11, 2013



India’s current account deficit (CAD) hitting a record high of 4.8% in July and the continuous simultaneous steady plunging of the rupee, which has not bottomed out yet, has become a major source of worry for the country.

The depreciation of the rupee (15% against the dollar since January) will result in the cost of future import of goods such as petroleum, coal, and non-essential items such as gold shooting up. The situation has been created by a complex set of factors and the solution will, as a result, need to be multilayered.

It is clear that one part of the solution lies in the curbing of imports. Curbing of gold import has been widely discussed as a means to reduce this deficit, but there are other, equally important, measures that merit scrutiny, such as the tackling of the country’s energy import bill.

Coal’s contribution: imports and capital outflow
Energy imports (oil + coal) account for close to 40% of India’s total imports, with the country importing over 80% of its petroleum requirements at high international prices. Massive expansion of coal based power infrastructure and severe constraints on domestic production, have seen India’s coal imports rise sharply over the last few years. The coal import bill touched nearly $18 billion in 2012-13, more than double the 2010-11 figures. Coal imports jumped 33% in the quarter ending on 30th June, this is was up 44% up against last year ago. According to rough calculations the coal import bill by 2017 could account for 23% of the CAD.
 

Year         Import Quantity (in MT)    Import Cost (in billion.USD)
2009-10    73.2                                7.06
2010-11    68.91                              7.49
2011-12    102.8                             14.21
2012-13    204                                 18

Indian companies have invested significant amounts in Australian, Indonesian and other coal mines and power plants contributing to substantial capital outflow and a weakening of the rupee. For example, Adani Power and GVK are investing $21 billion in the Australian Galilee coal basin and related coal infrastructure. Lanco is also focusing on investments in Australia. Tata and Reliance is investing in Indonesia and even CIL is scouting for mines overseas. These international buys also require a large outflow of forex which contributes to the increasing CAD.

Finally, beyond these two factors - coal imports and coal related Indian investments abroad -  there are other ways in which coal contributes to weakening of the rupee and increasing CAD, like importing coal mining and coal power plant equipment and Indian coal miners/IPPs drawing on foreign currency loans.

Local coal is no solution
These figures have grave implications for the country’s energy security. There are at least two obvious solutions to the problem of energy import dependence:
I. Ramp up domestic production to meet entire demand, or
II. Shift away from coal dependent power infrastructure so as to wean off coal

The first solution is premised on the assumption that domestic production can, in fact, be ramped up to meet current and future demand. This assumes vast cheaply extractable coal reserves; local communities that can be easily displaced with no opposition; environmental regulations that can be flouted and offer no protection for forests, tigers and elephants that inhabit coal-rich areas.

Each of these assumptions is either false or misplaced or questionable:

• Coal India Limited (CIL) has recently downwardly revised its extractable reserve figures by 16% when it shifted from an archaic classification system to the internationally recognized UNFC system. There is reason to believe that the actual reserves may be even smaller. Recent developments have shown that communities in coal bearing areas have begun to exercise the rights given to them under the constitution, making land acquisition more difficult.

• Environment laws are being tightened to ensure that densely forested areas that support biodiversity and forest dependent communities will become off limits to mining.

CIL has not been able to meet local coal demand even when facing less opposition. The company has been consistently missing its own production targets. Recently, an inter-ministerial group reviewing coal supply to the power sector has recommended that the government stop accepting fresh applications for coal for the next two years in view of the acute coal shortage.

The only real solution left is a shift away from the current massive coal dependence. This would entail aggressively pursuing efficiency measures and investing in renewable energy solutions, both decentralized as well as large scale installations.

Arundhati Muthu is a corporate campaigner with Greenpeace India.

Comments

 

Other News

Sri Lanka too pulls out of the SAARC summit

India’s diplomatic heft in South Asia became clear when Sri Lanka too decided not to attend the SAARC summit in Islamabad.   With this, five members of the eight-member South Asian Association of Regional Cooperation (SAARC) have pulled out of the summit.  

Government wants to roll out GST by April 1, 2017: Jaitley

Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on Friday said that the government is working on a target date of April 1, 2017 for the roll out of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) in the country. He said that till September 16, 2017, that is one year after the provisions of the Constitution (101st Amendment)

Bihar liquor ban struck down

Within six months of prohibition being imposed in Bihar, the Patna High Court on Friday put an end to

Did India do the right thing by carrying out surgical strike in Pakistan?

Did India do the right thing by carrying out surgical strike in Pakistan?

Government eyes stake sale in more PSUs

 The government is looking to sell some of its stake in NMDC, NALCO, BHEL through the offer for sale (OFS) route. According to a news report in moneycontrol.com, the centre may divest through an OFS in companies that bought back government shares, in accordance with its plan to dilute share in public

‘High chance khadi will become extinct, if KVIC’s patriarchal view continues’

(1) The figures of khadi production and sales given by the KVIC chairman are in nominal terms, whereas we include the real value of production and sales in our paper. The same nominal figures, available in the latest KVIC annual reports, after adjusting for inflation based on WPI deflator, are used in our

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter