“Being Dog” and “Being Human”

What followed the conviction was enough to prove the Orwellian dictum that “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.”

shishir

Shishir Tripathi | May 8, 2015


#salman khan   #salman khan verdict   #salman khan hit and run case   #salman khan sentencing  

On Wednesday afternoon I was tempted to change a dialogue from Arthur Miller’s play ‘Death of a Salesman’. It reads, “I am not a dime a dozen! I am Willy Loman, and you are Biff Loman.”

I changed it to, “I am a dime a dozen, I am a dog and you are human”, and attributed it to the victims in the hit-and-run case. 

In this case, film star Salman Khan was convicted by a Mumbai sessions court for culpable homicide not amounting to murder and was sentenced to five years of rigorous imprisonment. His rash driving and negligence killed one person and injured four others, some 13 years ago.

Having stated the procedural fact the reason for tampering Miller’s play needs to be justified. What followed the conviction was enough to prove the Orwellian dictum that “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.” 

The manner in which Khan was made out to be the ‘victim’ in the case, when the court adjudged him the perpetrator, even belied Orwell’s thesis. It was like stating that all humans are humans but some are animals.

“Salman was in tears when the order was pronounced, Salman hugged his father before leaving for court,” stated a news report. It seemed that Khan was the victim and those killed and injured due to his rash driving were in the wrong.

I tried to find out the name of the victim in the case but sadly could not find it anywhere. Nobody was bothered about the real victims. What happened to them was not a question that was asked by anyone. People were concerned about Rs 200 crore at stake and saddened on the conviction of the “philanthropist”. 

The film fraternity which takes high moral stand on such issues and have made movies like ‘No One Killed Jessica’ and ‘Jolly LLB’ came in open support for the convicted actor.

Playback singer Abhijeet posted on his Twitter a comment in favour of Khan. It read, "Kutta rd pe soyega kutte ki maut marega, roads garib ke baap ki nahi hai I ws homles an year nvr slept on rd." (If a dog sleeps on the road, it will die a dog's death. The poor and homeless must not sleep on roads... I too was homeless once, but never slept on road.”) Abhijeet’s comment was criticised as insensitive and people reacted sharply to the tweet. If only Abhijeet would have seen ‘Jolly LLB’, a 2013 Hindi film based on 1999 hit-and-run case involving businessman Sanjeev Nanda, (also known as the BMW hit and run case), he would have refrained from making such senseless comments.

Boman Irani acting as defence counsel for the his client Rahul Dewan accused of killing people sleeping on footpath, says that footpaths are not meant to sleep and if one sleeps on it, one is prone to such mishaps. Arshad Warsi fighting for victims retorts that if footpath is not meant for sleeping it certainly is not meant for driving.

Actor Hema Malini told news agency PTI that "A law is a law. This is unfortunate. Salman's family are law-abiding citizens and they have already undergone 13 years of mental torture. His philanthropic work is well known and he is known to help the needy people."

 It left me baffled and wondering what point all the Khan supporters were trying to make by referring to his philanthropy. Were they trying to say that the best penance for the powerful is philanthropy and that can actually make their wrongs more human. Whatever the logic behind such statements may be the case was litmus test for judiciary which it failed to a very great extent in 1999.

In 1999, Sanjeev Nanda, then a Wharton Business School student, ran over six people, including three police officers. Nanda was initially acquitted by the trial court but in a retrial was found guilty in 2008 and sentenced to two years in prison, which was reduced to time served, a large fine, and two years of community service by the supreme court in 2012.

While Nanda was initially acquitted by the trial court Khan was convicted by the same and given a harsher sentence which clearly reflects the maturing of democracy and calls for some applause.

It at least sends a signal to powerful that they cannot take law for a ride just because they crush people by BMWs and Land Rovers and can afford Rs 10 lakh per hearing attorneys. At the same time the manner in which rhetoric was build around Khan as being a victim needs to be slammed.

Comments

 

Other News

Maharashtra FDA cracks down on `health supplements`; seizes stock worth Rs 1.39 cr

The Maharashtra Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a comprehensive state wide compliance order tightening regulations governing health supplements, nutraceuticals, sports nutrition products and foods for special dietary and medical purposes. The order, issued by Commissioner of Food Safety, Tu

States face rising fiscal pressure as spending outpaces revenue

States across India are facing increasing fiscal pressures, with revenue expenditure growing faster than revenue receipts since 2022-23, largely driven by rising subsidies and transfers, according to the annual ‘State of State Finances 2026-27’ report released by PRS Legislative Research.

Global value chains and sustainability

When a country’s factories become part of global supply chains, making parts or products that feed into goods sold around the world, the economy usually looks stronger. Output rises, exports grow, and technology improves. But the research behind this article [Bhayana and Nag, 2026] asks a harder qu

Narrative sovereignty in the digital age

In today’s world, competition between countries is not limited to military strength or economic power. It also takes place through the stories countries tell about themselves and the way others describe them. Social media and digital platforms have made this competition faster and more visible. Whe

The hidden cost of voter-ID link with welfare

On October 30, panchayati raj minister Rajiv Ranjan Singh, better known as Lalan Singh, told a national workshop in Delhi that Aadhaar would no longer be the basis for government schemes. His argument seemed simple enough. Aadhaar centres are now in every locality, and anyone can get a card made for anyb

The silent epidemic in the Northeast

In Mizoram, more than nine in ten people can read. Anyone there can find out how HIV spreads and how to protect themselves. Yet Mizoram has the highest rates of HIV patients in the country. If education were enough, this would’ve been solved long ago, but it was not. The answer tells us something a

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter