Have probe agencies done justice to 2G case?

The CBI court ruling reflects shoddy work by the investigating agencies

pratap

Pratap Vikram Singh | December 26, 2017 | New Delhi


#A Raja   #ED   #CBI   #2G   #telecom  


CBI special judge OP Saini’s verdict in the 2G allocation cases, which led to the acquittal of 17 accused including former telecom minister A Raja, has put the spotlight on the investigating agencies as the judge stated that the “prosecution case is without merit”.

Saini acquitted all accused in the two cases filed by the central agencies -- Central Bureau of Investigation, CBI, and Enforcement Directorate, ED -- and three companies. 
 
The telecom service providers whose licenses were cancelled by the Supreme Court 2012 order in the 2G case are now planning to sue the government for the losses they incurred due to license cancellation. 
 
The judge in his 1,552 page order said, "In view of deficient, or I may say nil evidence on record, I find myself unimpressed and unmoved, whatever may be nature of the case... Lack of commercial prudence in execution of documents cannot be used as a ruse to hold people guilty of corruption. The transaction was between private entities and in a private entity rate of interest, execution of securities, due diligence etc., depend upon risk aversion or risk friendly attitude of the persons concerned."
 
"Lack of these attributes in a transaction may, in a specific circumstance, indicate wrongdoing but for criminalising them specific evidence is always required. These assume significance only when matched with proper connecting evidence, which is lacking in this case," Saini ruled.  
On absolving A Raja, Saini said, "I have no hesitation in holding that there is absolutely no material on record to link A Raja with the above said transfer of Rs. 200 crore to Kalaignar TV (P) Limited."
 
"In such a situation, transaction of money between these entities cannot be designated as payment of illegal gratification for the official acts of A Raja, that is, for favours shown by him to STPL in the matter of grant of UAS licences and allocation of spectrum. Accordingly, prosecution case is without merit," he said. 
 
The ruling of the special CBI court reflects the shoddy work of the investigating agencies when seen in light of what the apex court observed in February 2012.    
 
However, let’s take a look at the history first.  The 2G story dates back to February 23, 2006 when the then prime minister Manmohan Singh approved constitution of a group of ministers (GoM) to “look into issues relating to vacation of spectrum” as demand for spectrum grew. It included the ministers of defence, home affairs, finance, parliamentary affairs, information and broadcasting and communication and IT. The terms of reference of the GoM included suggesting a spectrum pricing policy and examining the possibility of creation of a spectrum relocation fund.
 
On August 28, 2007, the TRAI made its recommendations. The TRAI, then headed by Nripendra Mishra,  said in its recommendations: “The present spectrum allocation criteria, pricing methodology and the management system suffer from a number of deficiencies and therefore the authority recommends that this whole issue is not to be dealt with in piecemeal but should be taken up as a long-term policy issue." However, it provided for exceptions in the spectrum bands of 800, 900 and 1800 Mhz, citing overriding consideration for level playing field.    
 
Telecom minister Raja, while adopting 'first come first serve policy' took support of the TRAI recommendations on spectrum pricing. 
 
Fast forward to 2012. The apex court, while striking down 122 2G licenses, noted: “To say the least, the entire approach adopted by TRAI was lopsided and contrary to the decision taken by the council of ministers and its recommendations became a handle for the then minister of C&IT and the officers of the DoT who virtually gifted away the important national asset at throwaway prices by willfully ignoring the concerns raised from various quarters, including the prime minister, ministry of finance and also some of its own officers.”
 
The SC noted in its 2012 order that "everything was stage managed". 
 
"As a result of this, some of the companies which had submitted applications in 2004 or 2006 were pushed down in the priority and those who had applied between August and September 2007 succeeded in getting higher seniority entitling them to allocation of spectrum on priority basis," Justices GS Singhvi and Ask Kumar Ganguli said. 
 
Cut to December 2017. While responding to media queries on what the government had to say and what it would do next, telecom minister Manoj Sinha said, "The agencies would decide the future course of action." Let’s keep fingers crossed.
 

Comments

 

Other News

Making sense of the ‘crisis of political representation’

Imprints of the Populist Time By Ranabir Samaddar Orient BlackSwan, 352 pages, Rs. 1105 The crisis of liberal democracy in the neoliberal world—marked by massive l

Budget: Highlights

Union minister of finance and corporate affairs Nirmala Sitharaman presented the Union Budget 2023-24 in Parliament on Wednesday. The highlights of the Budget are as follows: PART A     Per capita income has more than doubled to Rs 1.97 lakh in around

Budget presents vision for Amrit Kaal: A blueprint for empowered, inclusive economy

Union Budget 2023-24, presented by finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman in the Parliament on Wednesday, outlined the vision of Amrit Kaal which shall reflect an empowered and inclusive economy.  “We envision a prosperous and inclusive India, in which the fruits of development reach all regions an

Soumya Swaminathan to head M S Swaminathan Research Foundation

Former World Health Organisation (WHO) chief scientist Soumya Swaminathan takes charge as chairperson of M S Swaminathan Research Foundation (MSSRF) from February 1.   Founded by her father, the legendary agricultural scientist M S Swaminathan, MSSRF was set up to accelerate the use of m

m-Governance: Key to Digital India

The digital revolution is being led by India. Digital governance is a key component of the government's ambition to transform India into a society where everyone has access to the internet. It includes both M-governance and E-governance, which are major methods for the delivery of services via mobile devic

A sacred offering of the beauty of ‘Saundarya Lahari’ – in English

Saundarya Lahari: Wave of Beauty Translated from the Sanskrit by Mani Rao HarperCollins, 218 pages, Rs 399 ‘Saundarya Lahari’, usually ascribed to Adi Shankaracharya, has a unique status among the religious-spiritual works of Hinduism.

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now



Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter