Ayodhya imbroglio could be heading for a resolution now

25 years later, political situation is drastically different

ajay

Ajay Singh | December 6, 2017 | Delhi


#Babri demolition   #Rajiv Gandhi   #BJP   #Politics   #Babri Masjid   #Ayodhya   #Ram Janmabhoomi  
Prime minister Narendra Modi
Prime minister Narendra Modi

Former UP chief minister ND Tiwari had an interesting anecdote about the Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri mosque issue. In 1989 when he was at the helm in Lucknow, the dispute peaked following the posturing and counter-posturing by RSS-BJP-VHP combine and the Babri Masjid Action Committee. 

Rajiv Gandhi had gambled on Hindu consolidation big time by letting the lock of the disputed site open in 1986. But he was equally unwilling to let go of the Muslim constituency. His home minister Buta Singh became his chief strategist who drew a plan which goaded Rajiv to make a Hobson’s choice. A too-clever-by-half move was thus planned.
 
Tiwari was apparently averse to the idea of exploiting the dispute politically. But Buta Singh, ably assisted by an IPS officer of UP cadre, took Rajiv to the venerated saint of eastern UP, Deoraha Baba. As was his wont, the Baba used to perch himself atop a tree and shower his blesses by touching the forehead of the devotee with his feet. He did the same to Rajiv who asked him how he should go about this dispute. The Baba from his perch ordained, “Bachcha, ho jaane do (Child, let it happen).”
 
“Aur bachche ne ho jaane diya (And the child let it happen),” Tiwari once recounted, clarifying his position with a mischievous smile, in a conversation with this writer soon after his rebellion against PV Narasimha Rao before the 1996 general elections. 
 
Perhaps no political episode in Indian history is reflective of as much collective ambivalence of Indian polity as the Ayodhya dispute. It is a saga of indiscretions by constitutional entities, the judiciary and political personalities.
 
Rajiv was not alone in handling this issue not in a manner expected of a prime minister. Soon VP Singh followed suit as he was quoted by Arun Shourie as having told a VHP delegation, “Arre bhai, voh masjid kahan hai, voh to Ram Lalla ka mandir hai (That is not a mosque, but Ram Lalla’s temple).” However, VP Singh’s conversation to the outside world had a secular content radically different from what he said privately. The only exception was Chandra Shekhar who in his brief stint as prime minister in 1991 made a serious attempt to resolve the issue. But Rajiv toppled him within three months of installing him as the PM.
 
So far as the BJP is concerned, the party has always had a consistent approach to Ayodhya. In its manifestos, the BJP’s commitment to build a Ram Mandir was an article of faith that cannot be contested. But it was easier said than done when the BJP acquired the position of power. For instance, the Ayodhya issue is still dealt with as a title suit in the court of law. Obviously, the courts are not equipped to decide on issues of faith.
 
During Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s term as the country’s prime minister, this dilemma came up squarely before the government. And Vajpayee’s government couldn’t do anything different except relying on the court. During 1999-2004, the NDA government encountered the worst face-off with VHP and RSS on the issue. In the BJP’s scheme of things, Ayodhya was practically relegated to the background after the demolition of the mosque on December 6, 1992.
 
However the verdict of a three-member bench of the Allahabad high court in 2010 tried to address the complexities of the problem in the given social context. But it raised serious questions on the legal tenability of the judgment. That’s the precise reason why the Supreme Court has started hearing the case.
 
It will be pertinent to bear in mind that today’s political situation is radically different from the past. For instance, Prime Minister Narendra Modi is not coy about wearing his Hindu identity on his sleeves. His unflinching commitment to the temple construction may seem in conflict with his abiding loyalty to the Indian constitution. But there are indications that he has been navigating his way through political land mines.
 
And one of those indications came in the form of anointing Yogi Adityanath, a serving head of a religious body, Gorakhnath Peeth, as chief minister of the country’s most populous state. Yogi belongs to a genre of religious leaders who are most vociferous in their demand for the temple at Ayodhya. Of course, Yogi is a much mellowed leader now as his constitutional responsibilities far outweigh his religious incendiarism. At the same time, it would be extremely difficult for Hindutva hardliners to find fault with Yogi.
 
Obviously these are indications that the Ayodhya imbroglio will be heading for a different course, probably a resolution at best, with effective political and judicial interventions in coming months. It would be a tragedy if the issue continues to fester any longer.
 
[A version of this article appeared on FirstPost.com]

Comments

 

Other News

How a portal saved 2,000 lives by connecting patients with dialysis centres

As the city of Mumbai went into the lockdown in March 2020, those who were on permanent dialysis and caught Covid infection or suspected to have been infected were badly in need of dialysis treatment. At the same time a large number of patients who were already in dialysis centres started contracti

Tamil Nadu constitutes `Economic Advisory Council` with nobel laureates

The Tamil Nadu government has announced the `Economic Advisory Council` to the Chief Minister comprising Nobel laureates, Raghuram Rajan, former governor of Reserve Bank of India and various other economic experts from around the globe to advise the state on how to reverse the economic slowdown. The state

Kashmir valley railway stations get rail Wi-Fi network

 All 15 Kashmir Valley Railway Stations, including Srinagar, have now got integrated with 6021 Station Wi-Fi Network of Indian Railways. Public Wi-Fi, provided under the brand name of RailWire, is available at 15 stations such as Baramula, Hamre, Pattan, Maz

PM launches M-Yoga app on 7th International Yoga Day

The Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi launched the ‘WHO M-Yoga’ App while addressing the occasion of the 7th International Day of Yoga. M-Yoga app will provide many videos of Yoga training and practice based on common Yoga protocol in many languages. Terming th

Cinema and OTT will coexist: Madhur Bhandarkar

With technology evolving every day, it provides filmmakers ideas to get more creative and an edge to tell more stories. India currently has about 40 OTT platforms and the number is increasing by the day. With cinema halls shut during the pandemic-induced lockdown, people turned to OTT platforms in a big wa

‘Pandemic added to loneliness, isolation among elderly’

HelpAge India Report 2021, ‘The Silent Tormentor: Covid 19 & the Elderly’, assesses the impact and challenges of the pandemic on lives of elderly living in households (informal settings) and old-age homes (informal settings). It unravels some deep-seated fears of the country’s elderly

Visionary Talk with Madhur Bhandarkar, National Award Film Maker



Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter