Before accusing Nehru (or Modi) of economic blunder, read this

Jaimini Bhagwati’s new book is a detailed and balanced history of Indian economy since independence

GN Bureau | September 23, 2019


#Narendra Modi   #Jawaharlal Nehru   #prime minister   #diplomacy   #foreign policy   #Economy  


The Promise of India: How Prime Ministers Nehru to Modi Shaped the Nation (1947-2019)
By Jaimini Bhagwati
Penguin Viking, 385+xxix pages, Rs 799


Is Nehru to be blamed for all the ills plaguing Indian economy, with his protectionism and five-year plans? Equally, is Modi just a show-man with no concrete economic achievements on the ground? In recent years, Indians have been more and more divided in their political views and when it comes to economy hot debates go on without getting the basic facts right.

For all of us, then, Jaimini Bhagwati’s new book will be hugely helpful. ‘The Promise of India: How Prime Ministers Nehru to Modi Shaped the Nation (1947-2019)’ (Penguin) is to economy and foreign policy what Ramachandra Guha’s ‘India After Gandhi’ was to politics: a sweeping, magisterial back story to our present times.

Divisions of chapters by prime ministers here, as mentioned in the subtitle, are no mere ruse of story-telling: In India the economic and foreign policy-making has largely been shaped by the prime minister, following a template set by the first PM. It is no coincidence either that each chapter while detailing the country’s economic progress under the leadership of the prime minister of the day also touches upon foreign policy development during that PM’s tenure. In the cold war times as well as in the globalizing world, domestic economy has remained tied to international currents.

In that case, Bhagwati turns out to be the ideal author to tackle the subject: the former IFS officer has been India’s high commissioner to the UK and ambassador to the EU, as well as an MIT-trained economist with the World Bank and ICRIER, among other institutions. In these highly divisive times, what is most noteworthy about this book is its non-partisan attitude, as the author lists out achievements as well as weaknesses of one PM after another.

The watershed event in India’s economic history was the launch of economic reforms in 1991. It has metamorphosed not just the economy but also society and culture dramatically. The reforms have been subject of innumerable book-length treatments, and also an insider’s view of the history in the making thanks to Jairam Ramesh’s ‘To the Brink and Back: India’s 1991 Story’ plus Sanjaya Baru’s ‘1991: How P.V. Narasimha Rao Made History”.

The scene after 2004 too has been a well-trodden path. If the two keywords of ‘economy’ and ‘prime minister’ are put together, one would first think of Manmohan Singh’s decade-long term, and Modi’s five-plus years so far. Though the developments of this period since 2004 are too recent and specifics of them have been better covered in detail in other works, ‘The Promise of India’ gives a balanced account of the economic performance under the two leaders.

The real value of the book, then, is in dealing with the pre-1991 period, about which few accounts exist for the non-specialist reader. The opening chapter on Nehru sets the tone of the volume: balanced, detailed, perceptive, and yet thrilling to read. Bhagwati painstakingly paints the picture of Nehru’s times: not only in terms of economic policy-making but the first PM’s full task of nation-building, especially the institutions of democracy, while also battling the legacies inherited from the British rulers. (Protectionism, by the way, was the obvious choice after a decade that witnessed the Second World War, Bengal Famine and Partition.)

For those who grew up after 1991, this single volume will be sufficient to get abreast with the back story to what the western press calls the India Story. For a quick summary, either the R.K. Laxman cartoons over the decades, chosen carefully in this book, or tables in the appendix will be a good help.

Comments

 

Other News

Covid-19 antibodies found in 86.64% Mumbai citizens

As many as 86.64% citizens of the city of Greater Mumbai have antibodies, according to the fifth sero-prevalence survey. Among the people who are fully or partially vaccinated, the antibodies were found in 90.26%, while among the unvaccinated citizens, 79.86% had antibodies. The Municipal C

`Bad Bank`: All you wanted to know about NARCL

The cabinet has cleared the formation of ‘National Asset Reconstruction Company Limited’ (NARCL) which will acquire “stressed assets” of about Rs. 2 Lakh crore in phases within RBI regulations in order to address the problem of humongous amounts of bad loans in public sector banks.

Citizens Charter: How this less-known law empowers us

When consumer rights and RTI activist Mohammad Afzal was shifting to a new residence in a different area, he required changes in various documents. He decided to take the help of the Citizens Charter along with other friends who also required similar work with authorities. The Citizens Chart

Minister for Ports, Shipping & Waterways emphasises on setting up of National Transport Facilitation Committees

Union Minister for Ports, Shipping & Waterways and AYUSH, Sarbananda Sonowal has underlined the importance of cross-border connectivity among India and developing nations of South-East Asia. Addressing the ASEAN summit on Future of India-ASEAN Connectivity Partnerships virt

Ministry of Finance organises advance training programme in PPP for states

The Department of Economic Affairs (DEA), Ministry of Finance and the Indian Institute of Management Bangalore has organised a virtual advance level training programme on Public-Private Partnership. Additional Secretary DEA, K Rajaraman, Joint Secretary, DEA, Baldeo Purushartha

Ministry of Agriculture signs MoUs for Digital Agriculture

Modernisation of the Agriculture sector will continue by infusing new technologies so that farmers can increase their income, states Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar. The Ministry of Agriculture and farmer welfare has signed MOUs for pilot projects with Cisco, Ninjacar

Visionary Talk: GVL Narasimha Rao, Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha on Upcoming UP Elections


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter