Get real, Madam MP, don’t score political points over rape

Sushma Swaraj wants rapists to be given death penalty. With one Kasab hanged in 8 years, it would take some resolve to hang over 50 a day

shantanu

Shantanu Datta | December 18, 2012



Times Now is a news channel that understands entertainment better than most entertainment channels in India. So you have everything loud, jazzy and almost 70-mm, Dolby-like on the channel.

So when the channel does something, the honchos at entertainment channels, which primarily depend on the same sort of drivel to drive home their message and crank up TRP ratings of their medium, should take note. On Monday afternoon, the honchos at Times Now, which could be said to begin and end with the chief editor, decided India wants to see, hear and listen more about the national shame: the gang-rape and attempt to murder of a 23-year-old physiotherapy student in a moving bus.

So it cut live from Parliament, where the MPs were at their raging, emotional, tragic and vacuous best.

The point is not to run down the channel for showing the discussion on the tragedy live. No, it did all right — Indians deserve to know their MPs can get “outraged”, “shocked” and “sad” at issues other than scoring political points. But hang on, were they not trying to score a point, here, there and everywhere?

Sushma Swaraj, BJP’s uber-belligerent leader of the opposition in Lok Sabha, sought death penalty for rapists. Her demand, PTI reports, found support in the other house, too, party colleague Najma Heptulla, DMK member Vasanthy Stanley AIADMK's V Maitreyan. While Maitreyan urged the government to amend the law and introduce death penalty for rapists, Heptulla said, "Death penalty is the only punishment that is to be given. We can enact a law. This will serve as a deterrent.”

One is not getting into the positives or negatives of death penalty as a deterrent but a bit of number crunching would tell us why it’s not a demand worth the paper on which it would be reported tomorrow. According to National Crime Records Bureau, the number of rape cases reported in Delhi was 459 in 2009, 489 the following year, and 568 in 2011. Simple arithmetic says this translates to one rape case reported every 18 hours.

But the conviction rate in rape cases is just 26.4 percent across the country, with 83.6 percent cases pending trial.

While no one expects solutions to emerge in parliamentary debates, usually, Swaraj, Heptulla and Maitreyan’s was just about as unconvincing as pat solutions can get. India has 477 people waiting on death row; the last one, Ajmal Kasab, was hanged last month. The convict before that was hanged back in 2004.

Over to NCRB again: of 1.27 lakh rape accused facing trial in courts in 2011, the courts convicted 21,489. If all these were to be hanged as suggested above, simple arithmetic says that’s nearly 59 hangings every day.

Without getting in a noun like possibility, let’s just say: think for yourself. And think also about what MPs can, and should, do with the little time they make available in Parliament.

Comments

 

Other News

“Cancer is just a mind game”

Dr. Ananda Shankar Jayant, a Padma Shri awardee, inspired audiences for decades through her mastery of Bharatanatyam and Kuchipudi. But it was her journey through cancer that taught some of life`s most powerful lessons in courage and resilience.

Why Swami Vivekananda is the pathfinder for our times

Swami Vivekananda for Our Times  Edited and compiled by Rajiv Sikri, with Introduction by S. Gurumurthy Rupa Publications, 552 pages, Rs 695  

Five ways to realise the potential of India’s handicraft and handloom sector

India`s economic ambitions are increasingly defined by the industries of the future. Semiconductors, electronics, artificial intelligence and advanced manufacturing dominate policy conversations. Yet one of India`s largest employment-intensive sectors continues to occupy a surprisingly marginal place in ec

Beyond toilets: Why open defecation persists in rural India

Despite the awareness campaigns on sanitation across India, open defecation (OD) is practised openly and widely in both rural and urban areas. Research shows that rural respondents are well aware of the negative impacts of OD, yet this awareness does not lead to toilet construction or use. In rural North I

What unpaid nation builders want from policymakers

The Supreme Court recently described homemakers as “nation builders” and fixed a notional monthly income of Rs 30,000 for them in motor accident compensation cases. The judgment was not about wages. It was about compensation. Yet it inadvertently raised a larger economic question: If a homemake

What the US–Iran peace deal means for India

After months of rising tensions, the United States and Iran have reached a memorandum of understanding called the "Islamabad Agreement." This agreement allows for the immediate reopening of the Strait of Hormuz without tolls and provides Iran with relief from sanctions, depending on its complianc





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter