Mumbai activist takes over fight to get Mahanagar Gas in RTI regimen

Activist Milind Kotak vows to make gas giant follow CIC order


Geetanjali Minhas | September 26, 2013

Eight years after a Mumbai consumer activist sought an answer from the state information commission on why Mahanagar Gas Limited (MGL), like other public organizations, not complying with RTI Act, another activist has taken up the issue and is ready to move to the court again.

Milind Kotak, who runs an NGO called Forum for Effective Accountability and Transparency (FEAT) in Mumbai, has now taken up the issue.

Kotak told Governance Now that Kewal Semlani, who had first sought information from MGL, was only seeking that MGL should comply with the RTI Act. He said Semlani was a complainant under Section 18 of the RTI Act and not an appellant under Section 19 of the Act. However, in the final CIC order, instead of showing Semlani as the complainant, he has been erroneously shown as Appellant.

The story so far

Kewal Semlani, aged over 70 years, was the coordinator of NGO Mahadhikar. He had sent an e-mail complaining to the managing director of Mahanagar Gas in December 2005, on why the company was not complying with the RTI Act despite being a public authority. When he did not receive any response till April 2006, he submitted a complaint before Maharashtra state information commission. His complain was transferred from a single bench of CIC to a three member bench headed by the ¬chief central information commissioner who passed the final order.

The order said, “In view of the shareholding pattern and control of MGL that is apparently exercised by the government and the nature of the functions performed by them, it leaves no room for doubt that it is and be declared as a public authority’ within the meaning of Section 2(h) of the RTI Act.” It directed MGL to discharge its duties as ‘public authority’ within one month from the date of receipt of the order.

Challenging the CIC’s order, MGL then filed a writ petition before the Delhi high court (making CIC, respondent number one and Semlani, respondent number two). However, around that time MGL obtained the stay on the CIC order and Semlani passed away.

In its order dated July 16, 2009, the high court made a finding that NGO Mahadhikar  “had moved an application under right to information Act, 2005”. The high court, Kotak says, could have been wrong in its observation possibly due to an earlier error of CIC showing Semlani as an appellant and not a complainant in the CIC’s final order.

Based on this finding, Delhi high court directed that Mahadhikar be made respondent number 3 and told MGL to serve the amended petition on Mahadhikar within 10 days.

When the court bailiff went to serve the amended petition to the Mahadhikar office no one was available to receive it. It is also interesting to note that the advocate representing respondent number 1, i.e. CIC did not bring to the court’s notice that the finding was erroneous. It did not even offer to argue the matter in the absence of Semlani, when the court ordered service of the amended petition.

During its final order on March 23, 2010, Delhi HC held, “the impugned order of the CIC which has been stayed by this court cannot be implemented as there is no one to whom such information is given.” The advocate of CIC was found to be absent in this hearing.

This finding, too, seems to have been effected from the CIC order showing the senior citizen as an appellant instead of complainant in their final order. Based on these findings the court finally held, “In the peculiar circumstances of the case, this court directs that the impugned order of the CIC will not constitute as a precedent on the question whether the MGL is a public authority within the meaning of RTI Act. That question is left open to be decided in an appropriate case”.

Kotak says, “In case these erroneous findings were not made, Delhi high court would have directed the advocate of respondent number one, namely CIC, to argue the matter, which by now would have resulted in an order declaring MGL as a “public authority”.

Kotak has now decided to pursue the matter left incomplete, because of Semlani’s demise and make MGL comply with RTI Act. “We are corroborating all the required papers and are fully prepared for a long fight up to the supreme court,” he says.

Besides launching a mail id - for receiving citizen complaints against MGL and providing e-mail based guidance, on August 6, 2013, Kotak has also issued a letter to the managing director of MGL requesting him to comply with the RTI Act within seven days.



Other News

AI in education: How to embrace the change (and why)

It is often said that industry is at 4.0 and education is at 2.0. To transform education in line with artificial intelligence (AI), it is imperative to adopt what companies like Google are doing. We must learn to grow along with AI as AI is going to grow. There is a need to evolve the mindsets of educators

Diamonds are Forever: A Saturday story

Saturday Stories By Rashmi Bansal HarperCollins, 176 pages, Rs 250 From the bestselling author of ‘Stay Hu

Oracle Adds AI Capabilities to Oracle Analytics Cloud

Oracle has showcased new AI-powered capabilities within Oracle Analytics Cloud. Leveraging the Oracle Cloud Infrastructure (OCI) Generative AI service, the new capabilities assist analytics self-service users to more quickly and efficiently conduct sophisticated analysis and make better business decisions

Domestic airlines show 38.27% growth in passenger numbers

The domestic aviation industry has witnessed a remarkable surge in passenger traffic during the first eight months of 2023. According to the latest data analysis, the number of passengers carried by domestic airlines from January to August 2023 reached an impressive 1190.62 lakhs, marking a substantial inc

MPs bid adieu to historic parliament building, step into new building

A function was organised in the Central Hall of Parliament on Tuesday to commemorate the rich legacy of the Parliament of India as the Members came together to bid adieu to the historical building before stepping into the New Building of Parliament. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Lok Sabha sp

Real action, not words alone, needed to achieve UN agenda 2030: civil society

As politicians and policymakers make speeches at the United Nations during a high-level summit next week to assess the lack of progress on the 2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), people’s leaders representing some of the world’s most marginalised communities have come toge

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Current Issue


Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter