On the edge of the sickle

As farm distress impacted assembly polls, loan waiver is the buzzword. Telangana’s pre-harvest support scheme is a better alternative

sreelatha

Sreelatha Menon | December 31, 2018


#agriculture   #pre harvest support scheme   #loan waiver   #farm loan   #farmer protest   #farmer  
Illustration: Ashish Asthana
Illustration: Ashish Asthana

Farmers have at last forced the nation to sit up and take notice of what they are enduring. They marched to Delhi to protest. Then the assembly elections happened, and the defeat of the ruling BJP in three of its bastions – Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, and Chhattisgarh – is seen as a major backlash from farm distress. If there is one intervention, however, that agriculture experts say alleviated much of farmers’ misery, it was that made by the Telangana government.
 
The Telangana Rashtra Samiti (TRS) government launched a direct cash transfer scheme called the Rythu Bandhu Pathakam. Farmers are given Rs 4,000 per acre during the rabi and kharif seasons. This helps them take care of inputs and survive through the months of ploughing, sowing, and waiting for the crop to be ready for harvesting. It’s a scheme that global media has taken note of, besides the centre and the governments of neighbouring Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra. It has also repaid the TRS government of chief minister K Chandrashekar Rao with an election victory while big guns like Shivraj Chouhan of Madhya Pradesh, Vasundhara Raje of Rajasthan, and Raman Singh of Chhattisgarh were defeated.
 
Critics of the scheme, however, say that sharecroppers – burdened most by rural distress – are left out. Since the scheme sets no limit on acreage, the biggest beneficiaries are rich farmers with enormous holdings. Telangana, though, takes credit for pioneering an income scheme for farmers through direct cash transfers to their bank accounts.
 
Many experts have suggested such schemes. Former finance minister Yashwant Sinha had in a recent newspaper column recommended that farmers should be given Rs 6,000 per acre per crop season. He suggested an upper limit of five acres so that the lion’s share isn’t cornered by rich and powerful farmers. The former minister estimated that if the centre and the states share the cost 70:30, it would cost the centre '1.29 lakh crore, less than one percent of the GDP. Economist Arvind Subramaniam, a former adviser to the finance ministry, had praised the Telangana scheme and recommended its replication across the country.
 
Post-harvest interventions haven’t been as effective, especially when prices crash owing to glut. What happened, for instance, in neighbouring Andhra Pradesh, was that instead of hitting the usual '16 per kilo or so for farmers, prices plunged from previous years to Rs 2 per kilo. The government stepped in post harvest to ensure they got at least '5 per kilo by reimbursing them their input costs. Besides, they were to get Rs 2,000 per tonne of mango, provided they sold it to government-listed processing companies. Outsiders were not welcome. But the listed companies were soon glutted with far more than their production cycles could handle. So the companies kept farmers who turned up late waiting outside for days till they dumped their harvest and left. Farmers ended up losing money as rent accumulated on the tractor-trolleys they had hired for transporting the crop.
 
Chennaiah, a farmer from Chittoor district and activist of the National Alliance of People’s Movements, says 70 percent of farmers ended up paying through their nose for hiring the tractors and the compensation was of little help. Chennaiah was lucky: he sold 10 tonnes for Rs 6,000 a tonne and is expecting Rs 20,000 more from the government. “I didn’t have to hire a tractor so I could cut my losses. If prices fall again next year, farmers will have to fell their mango trees,” he says. Another farmer, Vijay, from Pileru in Chittoor district, says the government should have let companies from across the country to purchase mangoes from Andhra farmers.
 
Last year, a Telangana tur dal procurement experiment proved disastrous for all but middlemen and traders. Farmers usually sell tur in December, and the price in that month was low. But procurement opened in January and the middlemen and big traders who had bought up all the tur from farmers sold it to the government making an easy killing. Karnataka’s tur and ragi procurement plan, however, has benefited farmers.
 
In Madhya Pradesh, a price deficiency payment scheme – the Bhavantar scheme – was initiated, in which farmers were assured of compensation for the difference between support price and market price. This too was cornered by middlemen and big traders, partly because only 30 percent of farmers registered for the scheme. And the middlemen and traders squeezed the government by pushing prices upwards or downwards to their benefit.
 
The latest interventions from governments in Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh – the new Congress governments, that is – are loan waivers. “But these are temporary solutions, and farmers stop repaying loans expecting waivers as elections approach,” says Jaganmohan Reddy, a farmer-activist from the NGO APMAS.
 
The Economist magazine was critical of such interventions and noted that “since 2014, no fewer than eight states have waived a total of well over $25bn [Rs 1.75 trillion] in farmers’ debts.” It praised Telangana’s Rythu Bandhu scheme, saying this should be the way forward. Agriculture economist Devinder Sharma says in his blog ‘Ground Reality’: “Farmers have so far been subsidising the consumers by keeping  food prices low. What is needed is a fixed monthly income for every farmer taking into account his basic expenses.” Telangana’s beginning is a small fraction of what Sharma recommends, but it marks a new beginning. 
 
feedback@governancenow.com

 

Comments

 

Other News

How much time do you spend talking on phone?

How much time do Indians spend talking on phone? It is on average 761 minutes per month, according to a new report from the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI). The telecom regulator released its report, titled ‘The Indian Telecom Services Performance Indicators: July-Septemb

“Developing public health infrastructure key to sustainable healthcare for all”

Renowned cardiologist Dr Ramakanta Panda has said that the pandemic has exposed the inadequacy of existing healthcare systems and it is wrong to draw comparisons with Korea, a country with the population equal to that of a single Indian state. While speaking to Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Gove

SC-appointed panel on farm laws holds first meet

The committee of experts appointed by the supreme court to deliberate with the stakeholders on the new farm laws held its first meeting here Tuesday, with one of its members saying that all stakeholders, including individual farmers, will be heard. Hearing a petition on the farm laws enacted

India’s glitch-free vaccination gathers pace

The nationwide vaccination campaign launched Saturday, the largest such exercise in the world, has started setting new benchmarks, with vaccines administered to 2,24,301 beneficiaries in the first two days. “India has vaccinated the highest number of persons on Day1 under its COVID19 v

Maharashtra to spend Rs 2,500 crore to augment, develop power infrastructure

The Maharashtra government has announced a spending of Rs 2,500 crore annually to develop infrastructure of state-owned distribution company Mahavitaran (MSEDCL).   Out of the total amount, Rs 1,500 crore will be spent on energisation of conventional agriculture pumps and Rs 1,000 crore

Launched: Largest vaccination drive in history

India on Saturday began the massive vaccination drive against Covid-19, as prime minister Narendra Modi paid tributes the ‘corona warriors’. “Such a vaccination drive at such a massive scale was never conducted in history. There are over 100 countries having less than 3 cro

Visionary Talk with Dr Ramakanta Panda, VC & MD Asian Heart Institute





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter