Two drafts, two views: back to square one after final meet on Lokpal Bill

Govt opposes civil society's bid for an effective corruption watchdog

danish

Danish Raza | June 20, 2011



The 10-member drafting committee on Lokpal Bill failed to arrive at a consensus in its final meeting on Tuesday.

Representatives of the civil society and the government exchanged their drafts, which showed that differences on key issues persisted between the two sides.

Prashant Bhushan, one of the five civil society representatives on the panel said, "In today's meeting, for the first time we could see the government's version of the Lokpal Bill. We are really disappointed by their model of the Bill. This is only a symbolic attempt to have an authority by the name of Lokpal and not an independent anti-corruption body which we had visualised.''

HRD minister Kapil Sibal said, "Both the sides have exchanged their drafts of the Lokpal Bill. There are some points on which we have agreed to disagree."

The two drafts will now be provided to the political parties for their comments, after which the cabinet will pronounce its view and the bill will be introduced in parliament in the monsoon session.

Arvind Kejriwal, a civil society representative on the panel said, "All the differences which we had in the beginning with the government still persist. The government has proposed a very weak model of investigation whereby the accused will be heard before the lodging of the FIR and also during the course of investigation."

Significantly, it became clear in the final meeting that the government did not propose to bring the prime minister within the Lokpal's ambit even after he demits office. 

Earlier report: 

The government has hardened the stand on the issue of bringing under its ambit the prime minister, judiciary and the conduct of MPs inside Parliament.

Along with these longstanding issues, two more points emerged out of Monday's meeting - selection of members of the appointment committee of the Lokpal and the procedure to remove Lokpal. Anna Hazare's team said the government was pushing for too many politicians in the appointment committee which would result in conflict of interest. About the procedure to remove Lokpal, Prashant Bhushan, a member of the drafting committee said, "If anybody has evidence that the Lokpal is corrupt, then he or she should be able file a complaint with the supreme court and the court should hear the complaint the way it takes writ petitions. But the government says that only government officials should be empowered to move the court against the Lokpal."

When the talks began, Team Anna had submitted 40 principles to the government. Of these, the two sides stand agreed on 11 points.

The drafting committee will have its last meeting on Tuesday at 4.30 pm. "Now both the sides will work on their drafts, which will be exchanged in tomorrow's meeting. These will be merged and one common draft will be presented to the all-party meet and then the cabinet," Kapil Sibal, union minister for HRD and member of the drafting committee, said.

On its part, the civil society representatives will meet the leaders of various political parties. "We will brief them on our demands, said Arvind Kejriwal. 

Meanwhile, there are media reports that as per the government's draft of the Lokpal bill, the anti- graft body will be able to act against the PM only once he demits office. Civil society members of the drafting committee have called this 'useless'. "It is as good as saying that the PM will covered once he is dead. What is point of having a corrupt PM? He is a threat to the national security. If it is proved that the PM is corrupt, he should resign with immediate effect," said Bhushan.

Except for civil society member justice Santosh Hegde, all members of the ten-member committee attended the meeting at finance minister Pranab Mukherjee's office in North Block.

The meeting comes in the backdrop of a shrill exchange of words between both sides on contentious issues and government making it clear that it was opposed to bringing the prime minister under the ambit of the Lokpal.

During the last meeting on June 15, government nominees had asked the civil society members to present their draft while they will present theirs as there was no forward movement. It was also decided that a draft bill will go to the cabinet along with points of divergence.

In an indication that the Congress had hardened its stand, party chief Sonia Gandhi sent a terse letter to Hazare indicating her unhappiness with him for making his letter public and said she has already made her views "clear" on issues raised him.

Senior ministers held discussions last evening to fine-tune the government's strategy.

While the government has virtually ruled out bringing the post of the prime minister under the ambit of the anti-corruption watchdog, the Congress core group has favoured convening an all-party meeting on the issue of inclusion of the prime minister.

Government sources indicated that the meeting is expected to be convened soon after June 30 by which time the work of the joint committee to draft the bill will be over.

Senior ministers like P Chidambaram and several top party leaders have been maintaining there was divergence of views on the prime minister's inclusion.

Reports have it that the UPA constituents too have divergent views. They say that since the Congress is leading the coalition it has to take everyone together.
 

Comments

 

Other News

Caring for cancer patients: the expanded network of facilities

Health is a State subject, and the primary responsibility for providing healthcare services, including cancer care, rests with the respective state governments. However, the Department of Health and Family Welfare provides technical and financial support to States and Union Territories across the country

Capabilities, aspirations of India’s youth limitless: Modi

The capabilities and aspirations of India’s youth are limitless, prime minister Narendra Modi said in his remarks to the media at the start of monsoon session of the parliament on Monday.  "In the past month, the country has achieved many milestones, filling citiz

India gets the first hydrogen train

Prime minister Narendra Modi on Friday laid the foundation stone and dedicated to the nation various development projects worth around ₹14,700 crore in Jind, Haryana.   The PM positioned the city as a shining reflection of the good governance model. Emphasizing that the entire Haryana

Climate change is stealing sleep

Climate change has at least doubled the temperature-related sleep loss across 1,338 major cities worldwide over the past five decades, highlighting an emerging but often overlooked public health consequence of rising global temperatures. A new study by Climate Central estimates that between 2020 and

Cabinet approves Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme

The union cabinet chaired by PM Narendra Modi has approved the Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme (MPMS) with a budgetary outlay of Rs 62,500 crore. It aims to further scale up the production, deepen domestic value addition, strengthen supply chain resilience, enhance global competitiveness. It

Building infrastructure is only half the job

Recent stories of stolen railway wires, disappearing communication towers and missing public infrastructure are often treated as bizarre law-and-order failures of India. Yet they raise a more fundamental question. Why does the State often discover the disappearance of a public asset only after it has alrea

Upcoming Conferences





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter