Bombay high court converts death penalty to life after delay, Commission says that’d be injustice to victim
Geetanjali Minhas | December 14, 2019 | Mumbai
The Maharashtra State Commission for Women has urged the chief justice of India to take suo moto action in the matter of the Bombay high court converting to life imprisonment the death sentence of the two persons convicted for the brutal rape and murder of a Pune BPO executive in 2008.
Challenging the high court judgment of July 29, 2019 on grounds of “procedural irregularity”, the commission has requested its recall by the apex court.
On November 1, 2007, a 22-year-old woman working in a reputed BPO company in Pune was raped and murdered by a cab driver named Purshottam Borate (38) and his friend Pradeep Kokade (32).They were sentenced to death by the Pune sessions court in 2012. This order was upheld by the Bombay high court on September 25, 2012 and later also by the supreme court on May 8, 2015. A mercy petition of the convicts was turned down by the Maharashtra Governor and later also by the then President of India, Pranab Mukherjee, in 2017.
As for four years, one month and six days, from May 8, 2015 till June 24, 2019, the death sentence was not executed, the accused filed a writ petition before the high court on July 20. The high court upheld on July 29 that the delay of 1,507 days on part of the administration is “unavoidable / unconstitutional” and it converted the death penalty into life imprisonment.
“After 8.5.2012 the sentence of death ought to have been executed within 90 days. Commutation of death penalty into life imprisonment only on the ground of delay caused by the administration is miscarriage of justice towards the victim. Commutation of death sentence into life imprisonment by Bombay high court judgment is wrong when the mercy petition of the accused was rejected by the President of India,” Vijaya Rahatkar, chairperson of commission, told Governance Now.
The issue of authority of the high court in quashing death sentence of whose mercy petitions are rejected under Article 72 of the Constitution of India is pending in Union of India vs. Sonu Sardar - SLP (Cri) no. 008357 -008357/2017, says her letter addressed to the chief justice of India, SA Bobde. It also cites the case of Shatrughan Chavan vs. Union of India and Others wherein it was held that unnecessary delay caused in execution of death penalty can lead to commutation of same only by the Supreme Court.
The commission says that high court has gone ultra vires in commuting death sentence. “Such arbitrary commutation would be abrogation of rights and gross miscarriage of justice towards the victim. The judgment is not only miscarriage of justice but it has also caused huge social discontent,” Rahatkar writes in her letter.
India is battling the second wave of Covid-19 and infections are spreading into the interiors of the country, says Dr Anurag Bhadouria, National Spokesperson, Samajwadi Party. It is precipitated by the elections in five states, the Kumbh Mela in Haridwar and also panchayat elections in many states, he says
The CoWIN system, the overarching digital platform for citizens seeking appointment for the Covid-19 vaccine, is introducing a new four-digit security code” in the application from Saturday to minimise a peculiar error and subsequent inconvenience to citizens. “It has been notic
Mumbai, once the epicentre of the pandemic in India, has emerged as a model for all others in mitigating the crisis. The supreme court on Wednesday said the central government should adopt and take lessons from the Mumbai model to manage liquid medical oxygen supply for Covid-19 patients in Delhi.
A Functioning Anarchy? Essays For Ramachandra Guha Edited by Srinath Raghavan and Nandini Sundar Penguin Random House India / 392 pages / Rs 650 In a long and versatile career spanning thirty-five years, Ramachandra Guha has prod
To take preventive steps early and save lives, BrihanMumbai municipal corporation (BMC) commissioner Iqbal Singh Chahal has urged citizens to come forward and get themselves tested. Mumbai has seen a dip in Covid-19 cases in the last few days after an unprecedented increase in cases s
India reported 3,68,147 new cases on Monday, a number lower than the 4 lakh-plus recorded in the weekend. Also, more than 29.16 crore Covid tests were conducted across the country. As many as 29,16,47,037 have been conducted as on date. India’s cumulative recoveries now stand