3 carps on Rahul Gandhi’s Bhishma denial

The Congress vice-president’s vows sound wow but let’s come to the point: what exactly do they mean?

shantanu

Shantanu Datta | March 6, 2013



One day, many thousand years ago, somewhere near what is now the national capital lived a man named Devabrata. When his father, a king named Shantanu (ahem), a man apparently not known for his fidelity, like many kings of that era and later, fell in love with a fisherwoman’s daughter and wanted to marry her, young Devabrata took a vow that wows India till date: never to marry, to look after the kingdom all his life, and do away with the “high command” structure of the empire by democratising grassroots-level leaders.

Okay, the last one was not mouthed by Devabrata, a.k.a. Pitamah Bhishma, at least not in the BR Chopra version of the Mahabharat telecast on television. But Rahul Gandhi, a.k.a. the Congress vice-president and now further known as Bhishma-2, put his own spin on the big vow in an attempt to wow the nation in the run-up to the 2014 general elections.

There are different interpretations to what the Gandhi scion said — in fact, most newspapers and online forums put the words between the quotation marks differently — but shorn of pomposity and interpretation, they boil down to the above three:

* If I get married and have children, I will be status-quoist and will like my children to take my place.

* Asking whether you want to be prime minister is to ask me a wrong question.... The prime minister's post is not my priority. I believe in long-term politics.

* Stressing that the Congress's infamous "high command culture" must be axed for more democratisation, he said, I want to give voice to the middle-tier... empower middle-level leaders. There are some parties in India which are run by one leader, two leaders, five to six leaders and 15 to 20 leaders. My priority is to empower MPs as also legislators in states.

# The first could be a mild criticism of the Nehru-Gandhi clan: from Motilal Nehru down to Rajiv Gandhi — his great-grandfather all the way down to his father. While Jawaharlal Nehru’s entry into politics can be explained by the struggle for independence, no one asked him, and his daughter and her son to follow Motilal’s quest to hand over the throne to the progeny.

No one is asking Rahul Gandhi to marry but no one is even asking him to admit his offspring in politics. Just by sheer numbers and age of the party, his own family could be held culpable for bringing this “status-quoist” germ into Indian polity, and his party is perhaps the biggest victim of the disease spread by that germ.

# The second could be a mild self-criticism, having never been known to be too itchy to be in positions where he could be held answerable. He did answer after the Congress debacle in Uttar Pradesh assembly elections early last year, and he did own up responsibility. But no one in his party wanted it. There were far too many beavers eager to take the same blame for anyone to pay attention. And he failed similarly, though the extent of culpability could be deemed relatively lower, in most state elections where he held rallies since then, Gujarat and Tripura (where he vowed to “throw the communists out of India”) being the most recent ones. However, he did not bat an eyelid when anointed the party vice-president despite all those blobs.

No one is asking the Amethi MP to give up playing a Test match and jump into a Twenty-20 fray. Eyebrows are — okay ‘were’, now that he has gone public with his desire, or the lack thereof — raised only to check whether he even wants to bat.

# The young Gandhi’s third observation could be a mild criticism of everything — from the family, to the polity, to the party, and even his own good self. Imagine the hilarity he must have sparked among people in his own party when he asked state Congress leaders not to criticise their own chief ministers, and the Congress (high command?) replaced the Punjab PCC chief.

Democracy? Grassroots? Empowerment? Anyone? Fix an appointment with the wannabe bachelor and don’t-wannabe PM Gandhi for details.

 

Comments

 

Other News

India lost Rs 52,000 crore to cyber fraud in five years: DoT

India has lost more than Rs 52,000 crore to cyber fraud over the last five years, officials have revealed. Out of approximately 60 lakh cyber fraud complaints received, more  than 3,000 cases have been resolved and six cyber fraud setups have been busted.   On the occ

India must not wait for its own Ella

In many Indian cities, children learn to wear masks before they are old enough to understand why. That reality should alarm us far more than it does.   In 2020, nine-year-old Ella Adoo Kissi Debrah became the first person in the world to have air pollution officially recognized a

An ode to the cradle of humankind

The Alphabets of Africa: Poems By Abhay K. Vintage Classics, 280 pages, ₹499.00   Abhay K

Ahmedabad district railway network to be expanded

The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs, chaired by prime minister Narendra Modi, on Wednesday approved the Ahmedabad (Sarkhej) – Dholera Semi High-Speed Double Line project of Ministry of Railways with total cost of Rs. 20,667 crore (approx.). It will be Indian Railways 1st semi high-speed project

Indian Ocean more contested than ever: Western Naval Command Chief

The Indian Ocean is becoming increasingly contested and strategically significant as the Indo-Pacific emerges as the defining geopolitical theatre of the 21st century, Vice Admiral Krishna Swaminathan, Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief of the Western Naval Command, has said.   Spe

Why the judiciary needs much more than four more judges

India has a particular form of governance theatre: the bold declaration that appears to be action but is actually a way of avoiding action. The Union Cabinet on May 5 approved a Bill to increase the sanctioned strength of the Supreme Court from 34 to 38. The decision has been touted as a step toward judici


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter