Anna Hazare vs. Constitution

Is it War Against Graft or attempt to suicide?

manojkumarhs

Manoj Kumar | July 30, 2012



By questioning every established institution, Anna and his Team A are on a suicidal path. But there's no law to stop them. Hence the tragic derailing of the war against corruption.

Attempting to commit suicide by a person is an offence under the Indian penal Code. But what if some persons are causing a movement to commit suicide? We still don’t have a law to deal with such a situation.

Even the presence of a leading clan of legal eagles like the respected Bhushan father & son duo and enlightened luminaries like Kiran Bedi have not prevented Anna’s movement from attempting to immolate itself in the aspirational divide within the Team.

So much for getting carried away by the euphoria of August 2011 that they challenged the very credibility of the constitution and the institutions of state functioning thereunder.

Further, the movement initially started as a protest by Anna sitting on a fast for the maximum period permitted by the administration.

Having set up demands incapable of being met and refusing to scale down any bit, Anna & Co has now prompted to tread the movement on very thin ice.

What happens if the demands are never met in their terms? Has Anna or the movement or both thus embarked on a fast on to death?

Section 309 of Indian Penal Code makes attempt to suicide an offence. Fast to death has been held to be an attempt to suicide under Section 309.

In case of a person sitting on a hunger strike to get his demands fulfilled, the courts have held that if a person openly declares that he will fast to death and then proceeds to refuse all nourishment till the stage is reached that there is imminent danger of death ensuing, he can be held guilty of an attempt to commit suicide.

Unfortunately, with no similar law to deal with suicide of a movement, the immolation of this movement against corruption solely on account of the individual aspirational agenda of the team members within, the people of India cannot get justice even from a court of law.

Be that is it may, with the movement loosing its focus from ‘corruption’ perceived to have been at the core of the movement initially and hammering every institution of relevance under the constitution, death of the movement initiated by Anna is a foregone conclusion. 

If only Anna had taken the right leaves out of Gandhi’s movement for independence – to work within the system and be focused. Instead, Anna & Co have repeatedly equated an elected government and parliament with the British and attacked every office including that of the president.

People are left high and dry asking themselves whether Gandhi would have done some of the things that Anna is doing. Would Gandhi have tried to overthrow a duly elected government / constitution?  There is a difference in context between Britishers and our own government elected by us the people of India. Both cannot be equated to met out the same treatment.

How can a team comprising legally aware persons not know the difference? Have Team A’s personal aspirations, perceptions and priorities already derailed the larger issue of combating corruption?

Unfortunately, yes. What the future beholds for the movement is for anyone to guess.

Comments

 

Other News

Lines that unite, lines that separate

Lines and Lives: Stories of Conflict, Resilience and Hope from Jammu and Kashmir Borderlands Edited by Mohita Bhatia, Rekha Chowdhary and Sandeep Singh Orient BlackSwan, 280 pages, Rs 1,510

WEF, MMRDA ink deal to transform MMR into global fin hub

The World Economic Forum (WEF) will provide funds to Maharashtra government for making Mumbai Metroplolitan Region (MMR)  a global  financial hub. An MoU between MMRDA (Mumbai Metropolitan Region Development Authority) and WEF was signed by Klaus Schwab, founder and executive Chairman, World 

How to be prepared for the next pandemic

NITI Aayog on Wednesday released an Expert Group report, titled ‘Future Pandemic Preparedness and Emergency Response — A Framework for Action’. The expert group in the report has provided a blueprint for the country to prepare for any future public health emergency or pandemic and have a

The Shinde Saga: From humble beginnings to union home minister

Five Decades in Politics By Sushilkumar Shinde (as told to Rasheed Kidwai) HarperCollins India, 240 pages, Rs 599.00

How India can offer data protection to SMEs

Cyberattacks have become a daily phenomenon around the globe, especially in India. In the first half of 2024 alone, India has witnessed 593 cyber incidents, comprising of 388 data breaches, 107 data leaks, and 39 ransomware attacks. With an average of 3,201 cyberattacks per week in Q2 2024,

Sopan Joshi on writing “that mango book”, research and a “memorable” feast

Mangifera indica: A Biography of the Mango By Sopan Joshi Aleph Book Company, 432 pages, Rs 799 The mang

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter