Time to worry when CBI outdoes itself

The swiftness in the Amit Shah case is very selective

ajay

Ajay Singh | November 2, 2010



The alacrity with which the CBI approached the supreme court after Amit Shah was granted bail is only illustrative of the supine nature of the country’s premier investigative agency. Shah, former home minister of Gujarat, was jailed for his involvement in the brutal killing of Sohrabuddin and his wife Kausar Bi by the state police. The CBI has been probing Shah’s complicity in the crime.

Of course, there can be hardly any sympathy with a person involved in a criminal act, howsoever powerful he may be politically. Whether Amit Shah deserved bail or further imprisonment is for the courts to decide. But we are more concerned here with the conduct of the investigative agency.

Just as Amit Shah was bailed out in the night in gross violation of the jail manual, the CBI knocked at the door of the supreme court on Friday. When inquired about the urgency of the situation, the CBI counsels pointed out that Shah had been released from the jail in violation of the jail manual and that he could influence the witnesses. This patently absurd proposition found least acceptance with the hurriedly constituted two-member of the SC. However, given the fear exuded by the CBI over the possibility of Shah and his mentor, Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi manipulating witnesses and evidence, the SC interned Shah from the state.

Contrast this scenario with the CBI’s handling of cases related to politicians belonging to the ruling dispensation. Despite the SC’s stricture on the CBI’s probe into the 2G scam, the agency showed undue reluctance to proceed with the case. Similarly, in an overnight decision, the account of Italian businessman Ottavio Quttrochi was de-freezed  in London allowing him to spirit away the money to a safe haven.

In the cases related to the disproportionate assets of Mayawati and Mulayam Singh Yadav, the agency’s pace of investigation is apparently dictated by the ruling coalition’s political requirements. Going by the agency’s proclivity to please its political masters, it can be safely assumed that the agency has bartered its autonomy to the central government for a pittance. Unfortunately, the CBI has been getting successive directors who are ready to crawl if asked to bend by the political establishment. Only an exception can save the CBI.

Comments

 

Other News

Election Results: NC-Cong leads in J&K, BJP in Haryana

The vote counting on Tuesday after the assembly elections of Jammu & Kashmir and Haryana has been mostly on predictable lines, except for a twist: in J&K, as expected, the National Conference in alliance with the Congress is on the way to securing a creditable mandate, but in Haryana the BJP is pro

NCERT ties up with Amazon to make textbooks more accessible

Union minister for education Dharmendra Pradhan on Monday presided over the signing of a Letter of Engagement (LoE) between NCERT and Amazon Seller Services Pvt Ltd. This is the first such tie-up, which will ensure access to original NCERT textbooks at the printed price on major e-commerce platforms.

DoT combats cyber-frauds: System soon to stop spoofed calls

In recent times, citizens have been receiving many fraudulent calls, often disguised as originating from Indian mobile numbers. These calls are in fact manipulated by cyber-criminals operating from abroad. These criminals exploit the Calling Line Identity (CLI) to mask the actual origin of the calls, which

Deep history of our languages show who we Indians are

Discovering India Anew: Out of Africa to Its Early History (Second Edition) By Alan Machado (Prabhu) Orient BlackSwan, 356 pages, Rs 750

Polling concludes for J&K assembly

The polling for the Jammu & Kashmir legislative assembly elections concluded on Tuesday in a peaceful and celebratory atmosphere. Scenes of voters patiently waiting in lines at polling stations, set against the scenic backdrop of the region, highlighted the people`s strong faith in democracy. The festi

Advancing green growth via bio-manufacturing and bio-foundry initiative

In the ongoing problem of facing environmental challenges, the call for sustainable practices has become more pressing than ever. Nations have started to strive to reduce their carbon footprint and mitigate the adverse effects of industrialization, innovative solutions are imperative. Unfortunately, due to

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter