Who wants Lokpal anyway? Not Congress, for sure

The weak bill and the reckless politicisation of house debates would suggest otherwise

brajesh

Brajesh Kumar | December 29, 2011



After 43 years of dithering on the anti-corruption bill, the Lok Sabha finally passed the newest version of the Lokpal bill late Tuesday. The bill, thus, is now past the first hurdle.

However, an united opposition thouroughly lambasted the government in the house for bringing a 'patently unconstitutional and deeply flawed bill' and for 'violating the spirit of consenus. Going by the uproar in Lok Sabha, chances are the bill will fall through in the Rajya Sabha where the ruling coalition does not have the required numbers. It has just 99 members out of a total of 245.

However, such an event is in keeping with the UPA's scheme of things for it has never been serious about a strong Lokpal. UPA spin master and the legal brain behind the bill, Kapil Sibal kept blaming the BJP for "stalling the bill" throughout the debate and betrayed the government's true intentions.

“Their politics is not to allow Lokpal; tell that (sic) government is bringing a weak Lokpal and then go to election-bound states,” said Sibal in parliament.

Is it really so, Mr Sibal? While certain MPs from the opposition benches could be guilty of stalling the bill, the larger apprehension expressed by the opposition about the bill being unconstitutional and weak is certainly not misplaced.

By throwing the ball in the opposition’s court UPA’s gameplan is to divert and channel the Anna-movement fuelled anger of the janta away from it. Once the bill fails to pass in the Rajya Sabha, it can tell people that it had championed the bill in the Lok Sabha and that it was the opposition which flexed its muscle in the Rajya Sabha and ran its efforts to the ground.

What UPA fails to realise is that the act it is staging is there for all to see. It will not take a Chanakya to see through its shenanigans and skullduggery.

It is quite apparent that UPA deliberately tabled a bill that was riddled with infirmities. Not only has the government introduced the bill under article 253 which make Lokpal binding on the states (with a nominal clause of consent) which undermines the federal structure, it has unnecessarily queered the pitch by providing for reservation for minorities in the bill which is in direct contravention of a supreme court order. Then there are the many structural issues - who would CBI report to? What exactly would be the role of the CVC? What would be the investigating arm of the state lokayuktas?

While we wait for the Rajya Sabha to decide on the bill's fate, the government has brazenly exposed its distaste for a strong anti-corruption body. In the words of CPM leader Sitaram Yechury, the government's introduction of the bill is rightly ' just a public relations exercise.'

Comments

 

Other News

`Low-cost Carboplatin boosts survival in aggressive breast cancer`

Adding the inexpensive chemotherapy drug Carboplatin to standard treatment significantly improves survival in patients with triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC), a clinical trial at the Tata Memorial Centre (TMC) in Mumbai has found. TNBC is an aggressive form of breast cancer and lacks

Recalling the ‘start-up’ days of a global security services firm

A quiet transformation began in Patna in 1973 when a young journalist, Dr. R.K. Sinha, inspired by the heartfelt appeal of social reformer Jayaprakash Narayan to support ex-servicemen, made a bold decision to leave his Rs 250-a-month job that led to the creation of Security and Intelligence Services (SIS).

Financing India’s Green Shift: The Rise of ESG Investing

The environment is important for everything in our lives, whether at home, in school, or any other place of work and engagement. After all, given the concerns the planet is witnessing, finding solutions is becoming tougher. In India right now, as in any other part of the world, even though there is enough

India moves up to 9th position globally in forest area

India has achieved a significant milestone in global environmental conservation, moving up to the 9th position in terms of total forest area globally, as per the Global Forest Resources Assessment (GFRA) 2025, released by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) in Bali.  Union Minis

“Game” of cricket: Governance lessons from India’s favourite sport

India’s cricket journey is more than a record of sporting triumphs; it is a live case study in strategy, incentives, and equilibrium: the very foundations of Game Theory. As India prepares for its eight-match white-ball series against Australia, the world’s most-watched rivalry will again unfol

In this year of extreme rainfall, climate change has amplified deluge

Southwest Monsoon 2025 recently concluded with ‘above-normal’ rainfall to the tune of 108% of the long-period average (LPA). This is second consecutive year in the last decade to record above normal rains. Climate change has a critical role in driving the rainfall on the higher side, according

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter