US think tank's 'communal' survey stumps home ministry

Suspicious respondents alert intelligence after they find questions 'communal'

GN Bureau | June 10, 2011




Mystery surrounds an American agency carrying out a survey in different parts of India to know the Muslim opinion on some sensitive issues like placing Sharia over the Indian laws, Islam's role in mainstram Indian politics, and whether Islam is under any serious threat.

The agency quietly conducted the survey in 54 cities and towns, including Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and Hyderabad and it would have gone unnoticed but for some in a Muslim locality of Thiruvananthapuram becoming suspicious in March.

They nabbed and handed over to police five surveyors going around with a 93-page questionnaire and paying Rs 30 to a respondent who was agreeing to reply.

The Kerala high court has now ordered an investigation to nail the people behind the mischievous survey after the union home ministry and intelligence bureau (IB) pleaded clueless about the exercise going on in the country for the past six months.

The survey was being conducted by TNS (Taylor Nelson Sofres) India, a research company claiming a network in over 75 countries. It has claimed that the survey was undertaken at the instance of Princeton Survey Research Associates International (PSRA), a US think tank specialising in socio-political research.

It sought to wriggle out of teh controversy stating that only around 590 out of 6000 persons interviewed across the country, that is less than 12 per cent, were Muslims. It insisted that there is no communal angle to the survey, and it was basically meant to learn and understand attitudes, opinions and values of people around the world. The survey is being conducted in more than 20 countries, it said.

Kerala Police chief Jacob Punnose says the survey had communal overtones and hence a case has been filed against TNS India for asking communally sensitive questions. "We have decided to file a case of 153(a) under Indian Penal Code (IPC) which relates to the charge of promoting enmity between groups on grounds of religion and race.

There are some questions that are US-centric like whether American ways of doing business are good, whether American efforts to spread democracy around the world are bad and to what extent people agree or disagree that United States is anti-Muslim.

If one answers in affirmative that US is anti-Muslim, the questionnaire goes on to ask why such a view is being supported. Is it because US kills Muslims or carries out war on terror and war in Iraq and Afghanistan, or because it is trying to control and dominate the Muslim world, or it works against Muslim interests, disrespects Islam and supports Israel.There are also questions like which country offers the best model for governing a Muslim country and listed among them are Bangladesh, Egypt, India, Iran, Jordan, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Turkey or any other, in that order. The survey goes on to ask which countries offer the next best model for governing a Muslim country, running the same list of the countries.

Yet another question seeks opinion on some of the top Islamic leaders including Osama bin Laden, Pakistan president Asif Ali Zardari, Bangladesh prime minister Sheikh Hasina,  Saudi king Abdullah and Iran president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

Comments

 

Other News

Turning headlines into tailwinds

India’s Economic Survey 2025–26, tabled in Parliament on January 29, delivers a candid and confident assessment of the economy at a turbulent global moment. Growth remains robust at 7.4% in FY26, driven largely by domestic demand and macroeconomic resilience. Yet the Survey is equally clear-eye

Economic Survey: GDP growth for FY26 pegged at 7.4%

India’s GDP growth for FY26 is estimated at 7.4 per cent driven by the double engine of consumption and investment. This reaffirms India’s status as the fastest-growing major economy for the fourth consecutive year. This was highlight of the Economic Survey 2025-26 tabled by the finance ministe

The Bishnois’ Dharma-based eco protection shows the way for climate action

Before environmentalism had a name, it had martyrs. ‘Bishnois and the Blackbuck: Can Dharma Save the Environment?’ by Anu Lall tells the remarkable story of a community that turned faith into the world’s longest-running conservation practice.   

Ajit Pawar dies in plane crash

Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister and Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) leader Ajit Pawar and five others were killed Wednesday morning after a private aircraft carrying them crashed while landing at Baramati airport in Pune district. No one on board survived the accident, officials confirmed.

India concludes its largest trade deal with EU

India on Tuesday concluded the largest Free Trade Agreement (FTA) in its history with the European Union.  “It is a happy coincidence that on the 27th day of the month, India is entering into this FTA with the 27 Member States of the European Union,” prime minister Narendra

Climate risks may outpace insurability of India’s infrastructure: Report

India’s capital expenditure on infrastructure expansion has crossed 3% of GDP, reflecting the country’s push to accelerate economic growth through investments in railways, highways, ports, power plants and airports. However, many of these large, long-lived and geographically fixed assets are be


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter