Parl's right to amend laws supreme: FM on Vodafone case

Justifies decision to amend the Income Tax Act

PTI | May 17, 2012



Government on Wednesday justified its decision to neutralise the impact of supreme court decision in the Vodafone case by amending the Income Tax Act with retrospective effect suggesting it was to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

Winding up a debate on Finance Bill in the rajya sabha, finance minister Pranab Mukherjee said parliament is omnipotent and has right to change any provision of the Constitution.

He said the government had to amend the Income Tax Act following the supreme court judgement to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

With the passage of the Finance Bill, 2012 by parliament, the British telecom giant Vodafone might have to pay Rs 20,300 crore as tax, interest and penalty on its acquisition of Hutchison stake in Hutchison Essar in 2007. The deal was signed in Cayman Islands.

"Indian parliament is omnipotent...It has the power to amend any Article of the Constitution," Mukherjee said, adding the government's decision should not be seen as disrespect to supreme court.

"It is not to ignore the constitutionally assigned responsibility of the supreme court...As judiciary has the right to interpret law, legislature has the right to enact law. In the process, if there are divergences of opinion it should be treated as confrontation, it is the honest difference of opinion. If we make an attempt of reconciling that honest difference of opinion, it is not wrong," he said.

Mukherjee said he had told UK Chancellor of Exchequer George Osborne "(what) you have done in your country and I have exactly done it". Government today justified its decision to neutralise the impact of supreme court decision in the Vodafone case by amending the Income Tax Act with retrospective effect suggesting it was to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

Winding up a debate on Finance Bill in the rajya sabha, finance minister Pranab Mukherjee said parliament is omnipotent and has right to change any provision of the Constitution.

He said the government had to amend the Income Tax Act following the supreme court judgement to prevent outflow of Rs 40,000-Rs 50,000 crore from the exchequer.

With the passage of the Finance Bill, 2012 by parliament, the British telecom giant Vodafone might have to pay Rs 20,300 crore as tax, interest and penalty on its acquisition of Hutchison stake in Hutchison Essar in 2007. The deal was signed in Cayman Islands.

"Indian parliament is omnipotent...It has the power to amend any Article of the Constitution," Mukherjee said, adding the government's decision should not be seen as disrespect to supreme court.

"It is not to ignore the constitutionally assigned responsibility of the supreme court...As judiciary has the right to interpret law, legislature has the right to enact law. In the process, if there are divergences of opinion it should be treated as confrontation, it is the honest difference of opinion. If we make an attempt of reconciling that honest difference of opinion, it is not wrong," he said.

Mukherjee said he had told UK Chancellor of Exchequer George Osborne "(what) you have done in your country and I have exactly done it".

Comments

 

Other News

STHAVAR: Why every Indian built asset needs a permanent digital identity

India has built digital systems for identity, payments, taxation, documents, logistics and public services. State governments, ministries, infrastructure agencies and urban local bodies have also created portals for land records, building permissions, project monitoring, property taxation and municipal s

Saksham Skill census identifies 22,000 job-ready candidates in one Mumbai ward

A first-of-its-kind AI-enabled skill census conducted in Mumbai`s H-West Ward has identified a potential livelihood pipeline of nearly 22,000 candidates, generated over 32,000 provisional job matches while revealing that 71.2 per cent of surveyed homemakers are willing to join the workforce, according to

GI tags: Scaling traditional wealth into global brands

Geographical Indication (GI) tags have emerged as a powerful tool for protecting India`s cultural heritage, while creating economic opportunities for local communities. By linking products to their place of origin, GI tags preserve traditional knowledge, prevent misuse, and enhance consumer trust. They h

BMC: 207 officials in ACB net, 112 still on duty, 68 retire before justice catches up

There are significant delays in the handling of corruption cases involving officials of the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), a Right to Information (RTI) response obtained by rights activist Jeetendra Ghadge has revealed. As of 30 April 2026, 207 BMC officials face Anti-Corruption Bureau (A

The transformation trap: Why efficiency is not innovation

Every company is transforming, or so it claims.   There was a time when the word ‘transformation’ carried weight. It signified bold strategic shifts, reinvention of business models, and breakthrough technologies that fundamentally changed how organizations created

The Sardar biography that throws light on our times

Patel: A Life By Rajmohan Gandhi Aleph Books, 568 pages, Rs 1,199   There are many biographi

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter