While we wait for last-mile solutions, setting up common services centres in villages is an easy way to ensure internet access in the rural hinterland
Taru Bhatia | March 6, 2017 | Ghaziabad
For long, residents of Sultanpur village would travel 17 kms to the district office in Raj Nagar, Ghaziabad, if they needed to get birth, death or caste certificates or PAN or ration cards. If these documents were needed urgently, it was taken for granted that they’d have to approach a tout who would charge them anything between Rs 500 and Rs 2,000. A common services centre (CSC), established in 2014, changed all that.
READ: Internet, unto the last
“Earlier, I’d have to close my shop for a day to go to the district office. We all know how a sarkari daftar works. They take their own time,” says Munnalal, a shopkeeper who has been living in Sultanpur since 1972. “Now, this centre is just a few steps away from my shop. It’s a welcome change for our village.”
READ: “For connectivity, fibre can’t be the last mile”
The Sultanpur gram panchayat is among 1.7 lakh that now have CSCs, which are changing the way government services are delivered. CSCs were an integral part of the UPA’s Rs 30,000 crore National e-Governance Plan (NeGP), launched in 2006. The original plan aimed at having a CSC at one lakh gram panchayats; in 2015, the NDA relaunched it as CSC 2.0 with the aim of ensuring that all government services could be delivered electronically at all 2.5 lakh gram panchayats across India. The number of villages (as opposed to gram panchayats) in India is about 6 lakh, and the idea is that all villagers should be able to access government services without having to travel too far.
READ: "By Sep 2018, we will have broadband in every village"
The CSC in Sultanpur is run by Vipin Farshwal, who quit his well-paying job as advertising head with Amar Ujala, a Hindi newspaper group, to become a village-level entrepreneur (VLE), which is officialese for those who partner in the government programme. “The job was good, but there was no satisfaction. As a VLE, I have the opportunity to help people,” he says. “Whoever comes to my centre, I ensure that their work is done. Over a period of three years, I have developed a good bond with villagers. I have also been made a member of the block development committee.”
Farshwal operates from a one-room centre, where three employees help people obtain or have corrections made to Aadhaar and PAN cards, collect various government certificates, file complaints, apply for government jobs, make bill payments or recharge cellphones or internet connections. Since most visitors come with Aadhaar queries, he has assigned one employee to handling only Aadhaar-related work. Other queries usually relate to widow pension, income and caste certificates, etc. Farshwal says he earns RS 30,000-35,000 per month in commissions, which is enough to run the centre and pay salaries.
E-Governance Services India Ltd, an independent agency of the government for implementing and monitoring the CSC network, pays VLEs like Farshwal Rs 60 for every Aadhaar card generated at their centre. Also, of the Rs 25 charged for updating Aadhaar cards, Rs 20 is paid as commission to the VLE and the agency keeps the rest. There are commissions for rendering other services too.
According to the recommendations of CSC 2.0, VLEs are to earn 80 percent of their revenue from commissions on government-related transactions and 20 percent from commercial services like mobile recharges, ticket bookings and so on. “Initially, only certificates were available online,” says Farshwal. “There was no awareness. And there were no major services to be delivered. I was sceptical of this business model, and so were other VLEs. But after the NDA government launched CSC 2.0, every week we saw new online services. Demand is now going up.”
Farshwal’s diagnosis of the delay – and subsequent correction – comes from ground-level experience. It matches the diagnosis of officials from the implementation side of the project.
“The politicians [referring to the political leadership during UPA time] didn’t understand technology,” says a former information technology department official. “For them, setting up rural computer kiosks meant instant recognition of the centre’s work. But it was like setting up a shop where you have nothing to sell.”
The NeGP had three components: infrastructure, middleware and services. The infrastructure component included data centres, wide-area networks, and CSCs. The middleware comprised software and linkages between various state and central government departments at all levels. The third and the most important part was services, mainly those offered by the district administration, the centre, and the state government.
Trouble was, for some reason, the cabinet chose to approve CSCs before organising the services to be delivered – in 2006, immediately after the cabinet sanctioned the e-governance plan. However, the provision of services took four or five years – the reason why the official called CSCs shops without wares.
The rollout strategy for CSCs was as follows: the funding was largely from the centre, but the state government was to shortlist state-level service centre agencies (SCAs), which were private agencies, through open tendering. The SCAs were empowered to appoint VLEs to run the CSCs and were free to work out the details of the cost of setting up kiosks, sharing costs and profits, commissions on each service and so on.
A common complaint heard was that, in many cases, SCAs designed the contracts to favour themselves, extorting a maximum share of commissions from the VLEs. For thousands of VLEs viability was a nightmare: in the initial seven-eight years, there simply weren’t enough public services to offer. State-level services, such as those provided by district authorities, weren’t available online because the districts hadn’t gone online. Even today, the e-district plan hasn’t been implemented in over 100 of India’s 700-plus districts. Countrywide, agricultural and land records, and police, health, education and panchayati raj departments are still in various stages of being brought online. No wonder, in those early years, in Bihar and in many other states, VLEs ended up taking SCAs to court. Many SCAs, including 3i Infotech and Comet backed out in the initial two-three years. Almost all SCAs complained they had “burned their fingers”. Bihar, Punjab, Goa, and Haryana couldn’t roll out CSCs for many years. And many CSCs just shut shop.
Between 2014 and 2016, in annual submissions to a parliamentary standing committee, the officials have maintained there are over one lakh CSCs and two-thirds of them are transacting. However, the actual number of CSCs transacting daily, or transacting more than a few times a day, has remained low. Employees at the CSC E-Governance Services India Limited, the special purpose vehicle (SPV) created for the project, say the “numbers are inaccurate and often fudged”. And an official says, “We don’t put it (the information) online as it will attract criticism and complaints. If you want information, you may send an RTI application.” The number of CSCs acting as business correspondent agents (BCAs) – agents who take banking services to the village level – too is very low. According to the joint parliamentary committee, the number of CSCs approved to act as BCAs was 28,111, but in January 2016, only 11,089 of them were active.
In its explanation to the committee, the ministry had blamed the flop-show on: “Non-availability of broadband connectivity, lack of power, left-wing extremism in some states, termination of contracts with private service centre agencies, lack of e-services, etc...” And the committee had recommended that the execution of the project needed to be “overseen by a robust monitoring mechanism, coupled with structured planning and swift decision-making at the apex level”. It also called for addressing problems such as poor connectivity, left-wing extremism, inadequate power supply and so on.
Having said that, CSCs got a new lease of life of late, with Aadhaar and other social security-related schemes being offered online at full swing. Last mile connectivity to the CSCs is also being bolstered under the BharatNet project, and in a revised strategy, CSCs are being allowed to buy bandwidth from private internet service providers and even retail it to villagers by using radio/Wi-Fi technology.
“Earlier, VLEs were struggling to get services and now they struggle because there are too many services,” says Dinesh Tyagi, CEO, CSC E-Governance Services Ltd. “CSCs also create employment potential for people living in rural India. They play a critical role in enabling citizens, especially in rural India, to make them digital empowered and enlightened. And so, there is huge credibility in the entire ecosystem in the community they serve.”
Tyagi says his organisation is planning to make it mandatory for VLEs to register some Aadhaar-related activity by March 31 if they want to remain on this platform. Another important function CSCs serve as the country moves towards cashlessness is to take banking to places where banks do not have full-fledged branches. All it takes for a VLE to become a BCA is taking the rural authorised person (RAP) exam.
Farshwal is one of those who has cleared the exam. “For nine villages, there’s only one ATM and one bank here, so basic services like withdrawal and deposit of money will help people a lot,” he says.
Efforts are on to establish Aadhaar-enabled payment systems at these centres. “We have launched this system along with the National Payments Corporation of India, and there are 60,000 CSCs that can already deliver payments via Aadhaar,” says Tyagi.
VLEs are also doubling as trainers, educating people on going cashless. Farshwal, for instance, ran an eight-to-10 day campaign to educate shopkeepers and villagers in managing without cash.
Waiting for broadband
The biggest problem, though, seems to be lack of internet connectivity. “I’m waiting for the government’s NOFN to reach here. It will be much better then,” says Farshwal. He currently uses Airtel’s broadband connection, for which he pays Rs 1,100 a month from his own pocket. He has also paid a one-time fee of Rs 15,000 to erect a cellphone tower in Duhai, a small town in Ghaziabad.
Tyagi says his organisation is piloting a ‘Digital Village’ project, aimed at providing Wi-Fi connectivity. “With the help of the ministry of telecom, we are making villages Wi-Fi enabled. They have already approved 5,000 villages for the pilot phase. Some villages already have fibre cables. We will take the connection from NOFN and provide Wi-Fi to the whole village. Since we have the ISP licence, we will also be able to sell internet packs to villagers,” explains Tyagi. A tie-up with BSNL and Airtel has been established for providing bandwidth, and the project is under the ministry of electronics and information technology (MeitY). So far, the pilot has been completed in 600 locations – Haridwar, Faridabad, Pondicherry, Haryana and Jharkhand. If it’s deemed a success, it will be expanded to 15,000 villages.
For last mile connectivity, CSCs are proving a better alternative than private players. “For private players to create the last mile, the costs are very high,” says Tyagi. “VLEs are already there in villages. Part of the cost which is very high for private players, for VLEs it is almost zero. Their ability to negotiate for a larger network is also high.” Moreover, he says, VLEs are themselves the users. “Their business runs on it and therefore, they are the biggest users of connectivity. Thus they are willing to pay for it as long as it generates income. But making profit is not easy for them. Their flexibility in generating coupons for the internet will be as low as Rs 20, 50, and 100. Big service providers probably don’t have the flexibility to relax their internet pack prices,” he explains. “Our ability lies in trying to excite the community and prove that CSCs can be used to provide internet to villages...and it’s probably a better option than any other mechanism.”
Tyagi also mentions another major problem, not out of tune with the problems that plague delivery mechanisms for PDS, NREGA and the like: monitoring CSCs is a big concern, as some centres were found charging villagers extra for delivering services. Suggesting community participation in monitoring as a solution, he says, “We don’t do policing. They are rural entrepreneurs. I don’t want anybody to police them. Let the community do the policing. They will decide, if they don’t like one centre, they will go to another, VLEs should know that citizens have a choice and that their centres are not exclusive.”
(The story appears in the March 1-15, 2017 issue)
Mumbai, once the epicentre of the pandemic in India, has emerged as a model for all others in mitigating the crisis. The supreme court on Wednesday said the central government should adopt and take lessons from the Mumbai model to manage liquid medical oxygen supply for Covid-19 patients in Delhi.
A Functioning Anarchy? Essays For Ramachandra Guha Edited by Nandini Sundar and Srinath Raghavan Penguin Random House India / 392 pages / Rs 650 In a long and versatile career spanning thirty-five years, Ramachandra Guha has produced a vas
To take preventive steps early and save lives, BrihanMumbai municipal corporation (BMC) commissioner Iqbal Singh Chahal has urged citizens to come forward and get themselves tested. Mumbai has seen a dip in Covid-19 cases in the last few days after an unprecedented increase in cases s
India reported 3,68,147 new cases on Monday, a number lower than the 4 lakh-plus recorded in the weekend. Also, more than 29.16 crore Covid tests were conducted across the country. As many as 29,16,47,037 have been conducted as on date. India’s cumulative recoveries now stand
Nandurbar, a tribal and hilly district in Maharashtra with a population of 20 lakh, is an unlikely contender for setting a precedent for the rest of India, but under the leadership of district collector Dr Rajendra Bharud, it took several measures to augment medical oxygen supply ahead of the second wave o
RP Singh, national spokesperson, BJP, has praised Mumbai municipal commissioner Iqbal Singh Chahal for actively engaging with people and effectively handling Covid-19 and said that a good administrator will know how to navigate political influence and bring in good governance. “