Railway budget-Union budget merger: Let’s do away with general budget too

It is time the annual song and dance over the general budget ended. No need for a long budget speech. Just table the budget document. That’s it

rahul

Rahul Dass | September 22, 2016 | New Delhi


#railway budget scrapped   #finance minister   #Arun Jaitley   #parliament   #union budget   #railway budget   #railway budget-union busget merger  
Parliament house
Parliament house

Now that the rail budget has chugged into history, the spotlight needs to be turned on the annual financial statement in Article 112 of the Constitution of India – better known as the general budget that is in desperate need of reform.

Policy makers need to take a relook at the arduous and incredibly secret task to prepare the budget, getting the voluminous documents printed and then having the finance minister deliver in parliament a long-winding speech peppered with Urdu couplets.

Not to forget the photo-ops, of the finance minister giving final touches to the document in a well-appointed room, smiling and posing for the shutterbugs with a leather briefcase, and then the hugely popular photograph of security dogs sniffing at the bundles that contain the budget. It happens year after year.

The general budget is crucial for our economy, no doubt about that. But, can we cut the fluff and come straight to the point. Preparing the budget is an exorbitantly expensive exercise and a way has to be found around it so that money can be saved.

We need a budget so that we know how the country is doing. It shows us how the states are placed and essentially, gives us a quick rundown of the country’s financial health. That, for the common person, is important but not the interesting part.

The man on the streets listens to the drone of the budget, but the ears perk up when the finance minister moves to the part where we come to know what is going to become cheap and what is going to turn expensive. Invariably there are guffaws when the price of cigarettes goes up, and the colleague wanting to buy a car looks worried when he/she knows it is going to cost more.

While the economists may find delight in the number crunching, the common man is happy knowing how the budget is going to impact his pocket. Invariably, the most discussed part is about the income tax limits.

There lies the catch. Here we have such a long drawn process and the common person is just focused about a tiny bit. As a way of reform, why not table the entire document in parliament, but read out that portion which we all know we want to hear.

Though it isn’t the case that the general budget isn’t being revamped; the timing of the budget presentation was shifted from 5.30 pm to 11 am. Till now, the union budget has been presented on the last working day of February, this will now be advanced. The distinction between the Plan and non-Plan expenditures will now be scrapped.

But, all these are changes which are more cosmetic in number. What is needed is more drastic. Sharply curtailing the entire budget preparation exercise is one. Why have a large number of worried officials in various ministries scampering to gather data, when those same officials can be better utilising their time in improving governance and making public policy more effective.

If policy makers are so keen then they must go ahead and have the budget, but at a smaller scale. The documents, once tabled in parliament are in any way public in nature, so whosoever is interested can read it on the Lok Sabha website.

Just think about it. Without a budget to be presented, there won’t be a budget session of parliament. The lawmakers can utilise those extra days to think of ways to run this country better.

Alternately, ministries can put up their individual budgets on their website. If you are interested, just go and read it there. Simple.

A practice started in 1924 has now ended with the merger of the railway budget with the general budget. The general budget too needs to be reformed.

The only grouse that we don’t have is with the security dogs who are indeed doing their jobs diligently, even if it means sniffing at reams and reams of papers that contain vital economic data, which unfortunately few care to read in detail.

 

Comments

 

Other News

Global South: Health cooperation needs institutions to make solutions scalable

September 12 marks the International Day for South-South Cooperation, commemorating the 1978 Buenos Aires Plan of Action (BAPA). Forty-eight years later, its central proposition remains relevant: countries of the Global South can draw on their own knowledge, experience and innovations to address shared d

Reading the mind of Xi Jinping

As India prepares to host the 18th BRICS Summit this weekend, and as prime minister Narendra Modi is set to hold a bilateral meet with president Xi Jinping, China’s growing global influence and the changing dynamics of India-China relations will be under focus. But to understand where China is head

BRICS at 20: From economic weight to global influence

This year marks 20 years of BRICS, with India set to host the grouping’s leaders’ summit this weekend. The anniversary offers an opportune moment to assess BRICS’ growing importance at a time when the effectiveness of global governance and the credibility of multilateralism are under in

Former president Ram Nath Kovind on some of his unforgettable journeys

Triumph of the Indian Republic: My Life, My Struggles By Ram Nath Kovind Rupa Publications, 400 pages, Rs 795   All our presidents so far stand out, each for a different reason. Ram Nath Kovind, the 14th president of India, from 2017 t

Uday Kotak on history, Indian economy, growth and more

Pathbreakers: How 10 Visionary Leaders Transformed India by award-winning journalists  By Sucheta Dalal and Debashis Basu Rupa Publications, 304 pages, Rs 695  

₹5,000 crore saved from suspected financial fraud

In a significant gain for citizen protection in the digital economy, the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) has helped prevent suspected cyber fraud losses of more than ₹5,000 crore through its Financial Fraud Risk Indicator (FRI) within fifteen months of its launch on May 22, 2025. This money did

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter