CAG spots irregularities in ‘Zero Tax Companies’ -Governance Now

CAG spots irregularities in ‘Zero Tax Companies’

Audit shows that there were shortcomings in the assessments of several companies with large profits that reduced tax liability by availing various deductions

GN Bureau | August 21, 2017

#CAG #zero tax companies

The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has noticed irregularities in the way the income tax department (ITD) carried out the assessment of Zero Tax Companies.

Several companies that were having large profit from business and distributing substantial portion of the income to their shareholders as dividend, were reducing their tax liability by availing various deductions and exemptions available in the Act. Such companies referred to as “Zero Tax Companies”, were attempted to be brought into tax net by introduction of section 115J by Finance Act 1987, said the report no. 30 of 2017 (Performance Audit)

This provision was withdrawn by Finance Act 1990. It was re-introduced as section 115JA by Finance Act, 1996. Section 115JA was further revised from 1 April 2001 by introducing a new section 115JB whereby companies had to pay tax on their book profit/deemed income at a rate prescribed by the Government from time to time. Section 115JAA provided for allowance of credit of tax paid by the companies under section 115JA/115JB in subsequent years.

The CAG found that the ITD did not consider incomes in 22 assessment cases for tax under Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) though the same were considered for tax under normal provision. Omission resulted in tax effect of Rs 74.10 crore.

In 16 assessment cases, ITD did not consider the extraordinary/exceptional items for computation of book profit. Omission resulted in underassessment of income aggregating Rs 126.57 crore involving tax effect of Rs 23.13 crore.

The CAG report said that the ITD allowed in eight assessment cases deduction in respect of Debenture Redemption Reserve/Loan Redemption Reserve charged to the ‘Appropriation Account’ as claimed by assessee in computation of book profit under MAT involving tax effect of Rs 331.14 crore.

ITD on one hand reduced excess depreciation pertaining to earlier years due to change in method of depreciation credited to the profit and loss account in computation of book profit in eight assessment cases. On the other hand in six assessment cases, ITD did not add shortfall in depreciation due to change in method of accounting. This involved tax effect of Rs 5.16 crore.

The report went on to say that ITD allowed bad debts actually written off as deduction in computation of income under normal provisions in six assessment cases. However, while computing book profit under section 115JB, bad debts actually written off was not reduced.

ITD made disallowances on account of bogus purchases/undisclosed income/unaccounted income under normal provisions in 18 assessment cases, and not under special provisions of MAT, there being no provision for addition of such items under special provisions.

The income tax department made transfer pricing adjustments with respect to items which had direct bearing on the profit as per profit and loss account in 36 assessment cases during computation of income under normal provisions but were not considered for computation of book profit under MAT. This involved tax effect of Rs 93.05 crore.

Comments

Other News

`M`rashtra muni. corpns face major governance, citizen participation gaps`

A statewide consultation organised by Praja Foundation has highlighted major governance, financial, and citizen participation gaps across Maharashtra’s Municipal Corporations, calling for urgent reforms to strengthen urban local bodies in line with the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act. &nb

When children stay healthy, they stay in school

Learning Begins with Wellbeing The future of education is often discussed through the lens of classrooms, technology, and learning outcomes. Yet one of the most critical drivers of a child’s ability to learn remains surprisingly overlooked: their health.

India lost Rs 52,000 crore to cyber fraud in five years: DoT

India has lost more than Rs 52,000 crore to cyber fraud over the last five years, officials have revealed. Out of approximately 60 lakh cyber fraud complaints received, more than 3,000 cases have been resolved and six cyber fraud setups have been busted. On the occ

India must not wait for its own Ella

In many Indian cities, children learn to wear masks before they are old enough to understand why. That reality should alarm us far more than it does. In 2020, nine-year-old Ella Adoo Kissi Debrah became the first person in the world to have air pollution officially recognized a

An ode to the cradle of humankind

The Alphabets of Africa: Poems By Abhay K. Vintage Classics, 280 pages, ₹499.00 Abhay K

Ahmedabad district railway network to be expanded

The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs, chaired by prime minister Narendra Modi, on Wednesday approved the Ahmedabad (Sarkhej) – Dholera Semi High-Speed Double Line project of Ministry of Railways with total cost of Rs. 20,667 crore (approx.). It will be Indian Railways 1st semi high-speed project