2G: CBI oppose probe against Chidambaram

Swamy alleged that HM was party to conspiracy with Raja in deciding the price for spectrum

PTI | September 20, 2011



The CBI on Tuesday opposed in the supreme court a plea for probing home minister P Chidambaram's alleged role in the 2G spectrum scam case saying it is beyond its jurisdiction to entertain it.

Maintaining that the probe into the multi-crore scam during the tenure of former telecom minister A Raja was complete, the agency opposed the plea of Janata Party President Subramanium Swamy.

Swamy sought the probe alleging that Chidambaram, the then finance minister, was party to conspiracy with Raja in deciding the price for spectrum.

At the outset, both the CBI and the Centre questioned the maintainability of Swamy's plea saying he has filed a similar application in the trial court and the issue has to be decided by the special CBI Court.

The CBI said that supreme court cannot give such an order and it for the trial court to take decision on the issue.

"Questions of any further investigation or addition of accused in the case have to be decided by the trial court and not by this court," senior advocate K K Venugopal, appearing for the CBI, submitted before a bench of Justices G S Singhvi and A K Ganguly.

"Investigation is complete in 2G scam (during the tenure of Raja) and framing of charges is to be decided by the trial court. If the trial court finds that there is any wrong doer then it can add the person in the list of accused," he said questioning the jurisdiction of the apex court to entertain Swamy's plea.

"Magistrate has exclusive jurisdiction in the case," Venugopal said adding that once the investigation in a case is complete then it comes within the jurisdiction of the trial court and beyond the purview of the court monitoring the probe.

"The case is not a narrow one and it has a huge ramification," Venugopal said adding that "Swamy is riding two horses at the same time".

Swamy's plea was also opposed by the Centre, which said with the cognisance taken by the trial court, the issue exclusively falls in its jurisdiction.

"Trial court has exclusive jurisdiction to take cognisance and hear the matter and once the cognizance has been taken, it is the exclusive jurisdiction of the special court," senior advocate P P Rao, appearing for the Centre, submitted.

Venugopal said "every single document, filed in the supreme court, has also been placed before the trial court. He cannot ride two horses at the same time and that is what he is doing right now."

"Let him go and pursue the matter there in the trial court," the senior advocate said.

Swamy, however, refuted the allegation saying that his application before the apex court was different from that which was filed in the special court.

He alleged that the CBI was determined to give a clean chit to Chidambaram who met with Raja four times between January 2008 and July 2008 on the issue of fixing the price of spectrum.

"CBI seems to be determined to give a clean chit to the then finance minister, who is now the home minister," Swamy said.

Comments

 

Other News

AI: Code, Control, Conquer

India today stands at a critical juncture in the area of artificial intelligence. While the country is among the fastest adopters of AI in the world, it remains heavily reliant on technologies developed elsewhere. This paradox, experts warn, cannot persist if India seeks technological sovereignty.

RBI pauses to assess inflation risks, policy transmission

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has begun the new fiscal year with a calibrated pause, keeping the repo rate unchanged at 5.25 per cent in its April Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting. The decision, taken unanimously, reflects a shift from aggressive policy action to cautious observation after a signi

New pathways for tourism growth

Traditionally, India’s tourism policy has been based on three main components: the number of visitors, building tourist attractions and providing facilities for tourists. Due to the increase in climate-related issues and environmental destruction that occurred over previous years, policymakers have b

Is the US a superpower anymore?

On April 8, hours after warning that “a whole civilisation will die tonight,” US president Donald Trump, exhibiting his unique style of retreating from high-voltage brinkmanship, announced that he agreed to a two-week ceasefire with Iran. The weekend talks in Islamabad have failed and the futur

Machines communicate, humans connect

There is a moment every event professional knows—the kind that arrives without warning, usually an hour before the curtain rises. Months of meticulous planning are in place. And then comes the call: “We’ll also need a projector. For the slides.”   No email

Why India is entering a ‘stagflation lite’ phase

India’s macroeconomic narrative is quietly shifting—from a rare “Goldilocks” equilibrium of stable growth and contained inflation to a more fragile phase where external shocks are beginning to dominate domestic policy outcomes. The numbers still look reassuring at first glance: GDP


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter