Army chief's action unjustified: Lt Gen Prakash

Gen Deepak Kapoor had not applied his mind before changing his decision, he says

PTI | February 25, 2010



Lt Gen Avadesh Prakash, who faces charges in the Sukna land scam, has said that Army Chief General Deepak Kapoor had not applied his mind before changing his decision to initiate court martial proceedings against him.

He also said the fresh court of inquiry ordered by the Armed Forces Tribunal would help bring out new facts and clear his role in the entire case.

"That is right," Prakash told Karan Thapar on CNN-IBN's Devil's Advocate programme in which he was asked whether Gen Kapoor had not applied his mind while initiating disciplinary action (court martial) in the case against him after initially ordering administrative action.

Prakash said the disciplinary action, initiated after Defence Minister A K Antony advised the Army Chief to change his decision against him, was in violation of an Adjutant General Branch's earlier directive that once an action has been set in motion, it can't be changed.

"It (AG's letter) says once the competent authority after having applied his mind to full facts of the case decides to initiate administrative action and such action has commenced, at this stage to revert to disciplinary action is not only unjustified but also legally unsustainable," Prakash said.

However, the AFT had in its ruling on February 22 rejected Prakash's contention in this regard saying the policy was only a general guidance and "not binding in nature.

Prakash said the COI report from Kolkata-based Eastern Command was received by the Army Chief on December 22-23 (2009) and the latter took three weeks to issue him a show cause notice on January 15 (2010).

"I gave my reply on January 22. On January 29, I was given a letter, which says that administrative action is cancelled and disciplinary action is to be constituted against me," he said.

Prakash said the Army Chief took only three days since his reply to the notice before changing administrative action to disciplinary action.

Also, the letter to initiate disciplinary action against him didn't mention his reply to the showcause notice, clearly indicating there was no application of mind to change the earlier decision, he added.

However, Prakash refused to comment when asked if the Army Chief had not told the "full truth" couple of weeks ago when he said that he had considered the former Military Secretary's reply before ordering disciplinary action.

Asked why did he not complain against the Army Chief's decision right after receiving the letter on January 29, he said, "I had no time to complain against the action as it was the day of 'Beating the Retreat' when all offices in North and South Blocks close down by 1300 hours and I was also being given farewell when I received this shocking letter."

The retired official said with the AFT giving him an opportunity to cross-examine witnesses in the fresh COI, it will help "put things in the correct perspective" and bring more issues to light.

Comments

 

Other News

Global South: Health cooperation needs institutions to make solutions scalable

September 12 marks the International Day for South-South Cooperation, commemorating the 1978 Buenos Aires Plan of Action (BAPA). Forty-eight years later, its central proposition remains relevant: countries of the Global South can draw on their own knowledge, experience and innovations to address shared d

Reading the mind of Xi Jinping

As India prepares to host the 18th BRICS Summit this weekend, and as prime minister Narendra Modi is set to hold a bilateral meet with president Xi Jinping, China’s growing global influence and the changing dynamics of India-China relations will be under focus. But to understand where China is head

BRICS at 20: From economic weight to global influence

This year marks 20 years of BRICS, with India set to host the grouping’s leaders’ summit this weekend. The anniversary offers an opportune moment to assess BRICS’ growing importance at a time when the effectiveness of global governance and the credibility of multilateralism are under in

Former president Ram Nath Kovind on some of his unforgettable journeys

Triumph of the Indian Republic: My Life, My Struggles By Ram Nath Kovind Rupa Publications, 400 pages, Rs 795   All our presidents so far stand out, each for a different reason. Ram Nath Kovind, the 14th president of India, from 2017 t

Uday Kotak on history, Indian economy, growth and more

Pathbreakers: How 10 Visionary Leaders Transformed India by award-winning journalists  By Sucheta Dalal and Debashis Basu Rupa Publications, 304 pages, Rs 695  

₹5,000 crore saved from suspected financial fraud

In a significant gain for citizen protection in the digital economy, the Department of Telecommunications (DoT) has helped prevent suspected cyber fraud losses of more than ₹5,000 crore through its Financial Fraud Risk Indicator (FRI) within fifteen months of its launch on May 22, 2025. This money did

Upcoming Conferences



-->

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter