Govt liberal in R-day parade expenses but miser in farmers' compensation

Supreme court angry over endless litigation to stall compensation payment in land acquisition cases

GN Bureau | February 12, 2015


#republic day   #farmers compensation   #supreme court   #nation news   #india news  

This was bound to happen. The Supreme Court has pulled up the central government for engaging in endless litigation over land acquisition issues and thus denying rightful compensation to land owners, mostly farmers.

"You have enacted the new land acquisition law for payment of compensation to farmers, but you don't pay the farmers for years. You (the defence ministry) spend Rs 100 crore for the Republic Day parade but when it comes to payment of compensation to the poor farmers, say Rs 10 or Rs 20 lakh, you file appeals," a three-judge bench of Chief Justice HL Dattu and Justices A.K. Sikri and Arun Misra observed.

"You say you have a national litigation policy to reduce pending cases and avoid frivolous cases. But then there are instances when even after the Armed Forces Tribunal had directed you to pay certain pension benefits to retired army personnel you did not pay and came to us on appeal. We had to dismiss the appeals filed by you (the Centre) against 900 pensioners. This is the way you keep on filing appeals," Justice Dattu told the cntral government lawyer.

The apex court was hearing an appeal filed by the Defence Ministry on granting of compensation to farmers on land acquisition in cantonment areas in Punjab.

The CJI also took a dig at the government for not providing infrastructure to various tribunals though appointments have been made to head tribunals like the debt recovery tribunal, national green tribunal and the income tax appellate tribunal.

"No accommodation is given to tribunal members and there is no infrastructure for the tribunals to function. You give accommodation in the Commonwealth Games village (in Delhi considered to be inhospitable due to infrastructure problems). Why are you making such discrimination?

"In one instance, even a retired Supreme Court judge was not given proper accommodation for heading a tribunal.... The debt recovery tribunals are located in flats. You first create infrastructure and then appoint tribunals for proper functioning," the bench said.

Comments

 

Other News

Urban Blind Spot: Animals, governance, and the cost of ignoring coexistence

India’s cities are expanding at an unprecedented pace, absorbing people, infrastructure, and economic activity at scale. What urban governance frameworks have been slower to absorb is a reality already playing out on the ground: animals are an inseparable part of urban life. From community dogs and p

How India uses AI in the field of culture and languages

* India is institutionalising AI for culture and languages through national platforms such as BHASHINI, Anuvadini, Gyan Bharatam and Adi Vaani etc. * AI is being used to make cultural and knowledge assets usable by digitisation of manuscripts, translation of academic content, and in

India improves position on Network Readiness Index

India has improved its position by four slots and is now placed at 45th rank in the Network Readiness Index 2025 (NRI 2025) report prepared by Portulans Institute, Washington DC.   The report, released on February 4, maps the network-based readiness landscape of 127 economies based on th

Framework for India-US Interim Agreement announced

India and the United States on Saturday announced they had agreed on an interim framework for an interim trade agreement, indicating a broad roadmap of the opening of the markets and reduction in trade tariffs on both sides. In a message on X, prime minister Narendra Modi said, “Great

India’s quiet rise as the world’s `Third Pole`

A silent re-calibration is going on in the international system, which is becoming more polarized, volatile, and entered of spheres of influence. The world does not evolve in the new era of bipolar competition of the United States and China, nor does it evolve on the setback of Russia in the role of a spoi

‘Tariff king’ to trade partner: Why Trump’s sudden U-turn surprises India

On February 2 at around 10 PM, Sergio Gor, who had become US ambassador to India just three weeks ago, posted a cryptic message on his official handle on X, stating, “President Trump just spoke with Prime Minister Modi. STAY TUNED….” This created a buzz across media in India as the two l


Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter