How not to manage crowds

Railways' ban on platform tickets between 1-4 p.m. shows us how exactly under-skilled it is in crowd management

shivani

Shivani Chaturvedi | June 4, 2010


The crowd at the platform ticket counter at New Delhi railway station
The crowd at the platform ticket counter at New Delhi railway station

Not much seems to have changed at the New Delhi railway station in the aftermath of the recent stampede. In fact, weakly strategised crowd management efforts threaten to boomerang, promising accidents of a greater scale.

The Railways had earlier decided to suspend platform ticket sales in the afternoon hours - from one to four - to avoid unnecessary crowding of the platforms by non-passengers. But this has only made matters with quite a crowd collecting at the ticket counters with no inkling of the ticket-sales embargo.

With the platform-ticket counters on both the ground and the first floor of the Ajmeri Gate side of the station left unattended, a queue inevitably builds up at the nearest counter. The queue gradually swells to a crowd as seeing-off/reception teams try to coax tickets, or at the very least, some information out of the railway personnel present.

rail5

Ratan Kumar, who has come to receive his nephew, has been standing here for over an hour. "I tried getting the ticket at the ground-floor counter. When I didn't manage to I came up here for a ticket. But then they asked me to go downstairs and check. But now I'm here again, still waiting for a platform ticket."

Such requests as Kumar's meet their immediate end in a curt,"You will not get platforms now," from irate railway personnel. They point at a notice stuck on the window of the counter. It just starkly reads (in Hindi) 'Platform ticket sales have been suspended from 1600 hrs to 1300 hrs to avoid crowding."

The later half of the notice announces both - the concessions that Railways is wiling to make for putting you through the missed seeing-offs and receptions and its lack of foresight in making these concessions. The notice reads, "Only those accomapnying elderly, physically challenged, children or women passengers may buy tickets during these hours."

rail2

But would not a simple task like getting a platform ticket get unnecessarily complicated if one had to prove that he/she has come to see-off or receive an elderly/physically challenged or any other passengers on the exempted list? And would it possible to always check this before giving the platform ticket?

With many climbing on to the counter-slabs, persistent in their efforts to get the tickets, a accident seems to be just lurking somewhere in the corner of that hall housing the counters.

rail3

Security personnel were missing from the scene till almost 1.30 p.m., the day I was there. Only when I started clicking pictures of the crowd did railway protection force personnel appear and tried organising the crowd even as a few railway personnel decided to overlook the directives and started selling platform tickets.

Divisional railway manager, New Delhi, Ashwini Lohani says that ticket sales were suspended for a few days after the stampede that killed two at New Delhi station.The new directives about the counters remaining closed from between 1 pm and 4 pm came later.

On being informed about the chaos that comes with the ban, Lohani assures us that the matter would be looked into.

Comments

 

Other News

Diwali now part of UNESCO’s Intangible Cultural Heritage list

Deepavali, the festival of lights, has been inscribed on UNESCO’s List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity. This was announced at the 20th UNESCO Intergovernmental Committee session at Red Fort, New Delhi, held from December 8-13, 2025. It is the 16th Indian element on thi

IIT Bombay launches Rs 250 crore deep-tech VC fund

The Society for Innovation and Entrepreneurship (SINE) at IIT Bombay has launched India’s first deep-tech venture capital fund managed by an academia-linked incubator -- the Y-Point Venture Capital Fund. With a total corpus of Rs 250 crore, the fund aims to accelerate early-stage deep-tech startups b

Revisiting anti-Sikh violence of 1984

Remembering the Past: Critical Perspectives on the Anti-Sikh Violence of 1984 Edited by Ishmeet Kaur Chaudhry, with a Foreword by Amritjit Singh Orient BlackSwan, pages, Rs 1,285

`Vande Mataram showed India the way to self-reliance`

`Vande Mataram` showed India the way to self-reliance. "It became a mantra to challenge external companies, which also expanded the mantra of independence towards the mantra of Swadeshi,” prime minister Narendra Modi said in the Lok Sabha on Monday, as he initiated a debate on the occasion of th

“All success is 99 percent luck, and 1 percent bloody good luck”

From Topaz in the 1970s to Supermax through 2023, RK Malhotra was the man behind one of India`s top razor blade brands. His unusual story is now told in ‘Ace of Blades: The Life Story of the Blade King of India’ (Jaico Publishing House). This is an account of a man whose obsession with the

India-Russia ties: Anchored in trust, deep mutual understanding

Unlike the US and the West, Russia does not have a relationship with India merely based on transactional exchange of goods or commodities. Instead, it is based on deep mutual understanding and trust, which have helped the two countries in navigating ups and downs of international geopolitics for decades.

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter