Governance Now Masterminds

Mumbai bridge collapse: BMC preliminary report in 24 hrs

This bridge is purely BMC structure, outside railway premises, says central railways spokesperson Sunil Udhasi

geetanjali

Geetanjali Minhas | March 15, 2019 | Mumbai


#Chattrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus   #BMC   #bridge   #Mumbai bridge collapse  
Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis at the Mumbai bridge collapse site (Photo: Twitter/Dev_Fadnavis)
Maharashtra CM Devendra Fadnavis at the Mumbai bridge collapse site (Photo: Twitter/Dev_Fadnavis)

The blame game between the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) and Railways continues after a foot overbridge collapsed near Chattrapati Shivaji  Maharaj Terminus on March 14. Six people have killed and over 31 injured in the mishap. The BMC has been directed to submit its preliminary report within 24 hours and fix responsibility of the tragedy.

Constructed in 1984, the bridge was declared fit by the auditors and was recently beautified with tile work. 

Maharashtra chief minister Devendra Fadnavis has stated that the audit had declared the FOB to be safe and has asked BMC commissioner Ajoy Mehta to fix “primary responsibility”. An FIR under section 304 A (causing death by negligence) has been registered by Azad Maidan police station against the railways and BMC officers. In 2016 an audit declared the bridge structurally safe.
 
In a statement issued by the BMC, the agency has directed chief engineer (vigilance) to submit preliminary report within 24 hours identifying municipal staff and structural auditor responsible for the incident. It has also asked chief engineer (vigilance) to submit report within one month for the cause of structure failure and reasons for bridge collapse, history of repairs and maintenance of the bridge, if structural audit was carried out in time, in a scientific manner  with required  methodology of appointing auditors, recommendations of last structural audit, if structural report was properly  studied and analyzed by municipal officers and actions taken by municipal officers on audit recommendation.   
 
“354 bridges were checked for their structural soundness and the bridge that crashed last evening was classified as C2B i.e., requiring minor repairs only. Tenders were floated but they were held up. We will investigate whether the tender was held up by the BMC standing committee or the roads and bridge department,” a BMC official was quoted earlier.
 
Activist Samir Zaveri who lost both his legs in a railway accident, said that the railways takes maintenance money from the BMC for bridges that connect with railway land. “While BMC pays money to railways for maintenance of connecting bridges it does not check their fitness or how work has been carried out,” says Zaveri. 
 
Speaking to Governance Now, central railways spokesperson, Sunil Udhasi, said, “Due to safety concerns railways keeps maintenance of public FOBs situated on railway land or tracks as they  have live traffic, live wires and passengers and does not give it to outside agencies. This bridge is purely BMC structure build and maintained by BMC outside railway premises and does not pass over railway tracks.”          
 
Experts Governance Now spoke to said that unlike earlier steel bridges made by the British, bridges today are made of concrete and do not allow if rusting has taken place inside. “Like buildings, every bridge must undergo a periodical audit. The portion of bridge that crashed down was on road and hence tiling and beautification work done recently on bridge was under BMC. BMC should have checked the structure before doing tiling work,” said transport expert AV Shenoy.
 
“With 1.2 crore population Mumbai needs single point governance like London and New York especially between railways and agencies involved like the BMC, PWD, MMRDA, MbPT, etc. BMC is supposed to have Apex Monitoring Committee for Roads where every two months representatives from various utilities like fire brigade, railways telecom companies, electricity companies, etc., should ensure coordination for projects like road digging, etc. No meeting took place since 2012,”added Shenoy, who was part of  the committee earlier.
 
Retired, BMC engineer, SN Patankar, said that due to sea Mumbai has salty air and bridges made of iron and RCC structures are prone to corrosion. “We have to see if loading conditions were changed due to corrosion or replacements of tiles and additional load. There has to be repairs of all bridges on a war footing by the BMC and railways within a fixed period.”
 
 

Comments

 

Other News

There is huge hunger for news, says Ashish Bhasin

India is a news-hungry nation with more than 1 lakh newspapers, apart from many news channels. News consumption is high – more so in smaller cities, and the industry needs to capitalize on its huge untapped potential, believes Ashish Bhasin, CEO, APAC, and chairman, India Dentsu Aegis Network.

Amnesty wind-up: NHRC notice to home ministry

As the Amnesty International downs the shutters on its India operations, the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) has taken suo motu cognizance of the matter and sought the home secretary’s response on the allegations levelled by the global organisation. Amnesty International in Ind

Covid-19 triggers research culture in Ayurveda, traditional medicines

The Covid-19 pandemic has brought the spotlight on the health-promotive and disease-preventive solutions of Ayush (Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani, Siddha, Homeopathy) disciplines. What has not come into the limelight is the emerging nationwide trend in the Ayush disciplines, of taking up evidence-based studies.

Derivative market for electricity in India: Will it lead to innovation or speculation?

The Indian electricity sector is going through an interesting phase right now. Many reforms are being introduced to increase competitiveness and transparency in the sector. The power market in India is a surplus market now and the spot prices are going down day by day. With all these indicators signaling a

A walk down the rich history of Ayurveda

The Indic Quotient: Reclaiming Heritage through Cultural Enterprise By Kaninika Mishra Bloomsbury India, 230 pages, Rs. 499    Over the past decade, India has seen a significant rise in passion for enterprise as well as pride in her

Is China gearing up for prolonged conflict with India?

International observers will keenly watch the Chinese Communist Party Central Committee meeting next month. The central committee is the highest organ of the CCP with a mandate to execute the decision of the National Congress which is convened once every five years.   Besides economy, r

Governance Now Masterminds

Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter