Uddhav voluntarily resigned, cannot be reinstated as CM: SC

Constitution bench says floor test called by Koshyari illegal


Geetanjali Minhas | May 11, 2023 | Mumbai

#Maharashtra   #Uddhav Thackeray   #Shiv Sena   #Eknath Shinde   #Supreme Court  
Former Maharashtra chief minister Uddhav Thackeray
Former Maharashtra chief minister Uddhav Thackeray

In a unanimous verdict on a clutch of pleas relating to the political crisis that led to the fall of Maharashtra’s Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) government led by Uddhav Thackeray following a revolt by the Eknath Shinde faction, the Supreme Court on Thursday said that Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Uddhav Thackeray  cannot be reinstated as chief minister as he voluntarily resigned from the post  without facing a floor test.

The court also said that former Maharashtra governor Bhagat Singh Koshyari’s decision to call for a floor test that toppled the MVA government was illegal. It held that the Koshyari’s decision without objective material to conclude that Thackeray had lost majority was wrong and not in accordance with the law.
“Status quo ante cannot be restored as Mr Thackeray did not face the floor test and resigned and thus the governor was correct in calling Eknath Shinde to form the government,” the court observed.

“Nothing shows members withdrew support and communication showed it disagreed with some policy decision of the Uddhav Thackeray government. Whether there would be deliberation or whether they (rebel MLAs) will merge with another party was unclear,” the court said as it underscored that the governor must use objective criteria and not subjective satisfaction.  

The SC further said the governor is not entitled to enter political arena and play a role in an intra-party or inter-party dispute and he could not have acted on the basis that some members want to leave Shiv Sena.   

The top court was hearing the issue of disqualification of 16 MLAs belonging to CM Shinde’s Sena. The 16 MLAs, including Shinde, were sent disqualification notices for not attending a party meeting convened by the then CM Uddhav Thackeray despite the whip which was issued.
The court also held  that Speakers decision to appoint Shinde group-backed Bharatshet Gogawale as the whip of Shiv Sena party was illegal.

The constitution bench of the chief justice of India, DY Chandrachud, and justices MR Shah, Krishna Murari, Hima Kohli and PS Narasimha referred to a larger bench the issue relating to speaker’s powers as laid down in the 2106 judgment in Nabam Rebia case. The court said that Nabam Rebia judgment did not decide on whether a speaker against whom a disqualification notice was pending could decide on disqualification petitions against MLAs.

The court held that the majority legislature party is not the competent body to appoint the party whip as that will amount to severing the umbilical cord of the legislature party with the political party. It ruled that appointment of Bharatshet Gogawale as the party whip in the house by the Shinde faction of Shiv Sena was illegal.

Speaking on the Supreme Court proceedings, Thackeray said that the assembly speaker should make a decision at the earliest. “As per the Supreme Court, now the speaker will have to consider our whip as it was appointed by the political party,” he said.
Welcoming the SC order, chief minister Eknath Shinde said, “This is the victory of people and democracy.”

Deputy CM Devendra Fadnavis said that all MVA schemes have failed. “All MLAs have right to participate in the House regardless of pendency of their petitions.”  

Maharashtra assembly speaker Rahul Narvekar said, “There was no clarity on Schedule 10 that whether a political party or legislature party can decide on the whip. Now that Hon'ble SC has given a clear interpretation we will accordingly decide. Earlier there was no clarity.”



Other News

Elections 2024: Why Mumbai and Maharashtra verdict is crucial

In the ongoing Lok Sabha elections, Maharashtra with 48 Lok Sabha seats is of crucial importance for the final outcome. In the 2019 election, the Shiv Sena-BJP alliance won 42 seats including six seats in Mumbai, as well as one each in Thane, Kalyan, Bhiwandi, and Palghar, which fall in the Mumbai Metropol

Jammu-Kashmir makes indelible mark on electoral history

In a massive stride for India’s electoral polity, Jammu and Kashmir has registered its highest poll participation in the last 35 years in the General Elections of 2024. The Combined Voter Turnout (VTR) at the polling stations for the entire union territory, which has 5 Lok Sabha seats

New study tracks heat wave; exposes dangerous trends in big cities

An unprecedented heat wave has been enveloping Indian cities, worsening the urban heat island effect, this summer. A new analysis by Centre for Science and Environment (CSE) says there are far deeper and longer term evidences on the nature of this changing trend that is impacting the biggest cities of the

Phase 6: Voter turnout 59.06% at 7:45 PM

Polling in the sixth phase of General Elections 2024 which commenced across 58 PCs recorded an approximate voter turnout of 59.06% as of 7:45 pm Saturday. In spite of hot weather in certain parts of the country, voters were undeterred in their enthusiasm as they were seen queuing up patient

Banks not adhering to RBI guidelines, finds study

Banks across India are levying inconsistent service charges on basic savings accounts. A study, “Benchmarking Reasonableness of Service Charges by Banks in India”, uncovers and exposes inconsistencies in adherence to RBI mandates by banks. It finds some banks impose charges exceeding reasonable

“Mumbai Infra boom similar to that of Manhattan in 19th C”

Mumbai’s ongoing infrastructure boom – with a new coastal road, Atal Setu, metro lines and much more – creating transport corridors – is comparable to that of Manhattan in New York during 1811-1870, according to BMC commissioner Bhushan Gagrani. The iconic projects being implemented

Visionary Talk: Amitabh Gupta, Pune Police Commissioner with Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now


Current Issue


Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter