Missing the cash

Are we getting desensitised to unaccounted for money because of rampant corruption in high places?

ashishs

Ashish Sharma | July 2, 2010


Nagaland home minister Imkong L Imchen who was detained at Kathmandu airport for carrying Indian currency notes of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 denomination which are banned in Nepal
Nagaland home minister Imkong L Imchen who was detained at Kathmandu airport for carrying Indian currency notes of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 denomination which are banned in Nepal

Money seems to have lost its shock value. Even in a country where 80% of the population lives on less than $2 or Rs 95 a day as per World Bank estimates. Else, why wouldn’t anybody be surprised over the Rs 9 lakh (some papers reported Rs 2 lakh) that the Nagaland home minister Imkong L Imchen was reportedly found carrying in a suitcase at Kathmandu airport? The media duly reported that the minister was briefly detained because he was carrying currency notes in denominations of Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 and that he was released after he explained that he was simply not aware that Indian notes of these denominations were banned in Nepal. But nobody appears to have been even mildly curious over the amount of cash that the minister was found carrying while returning from a four-day private trip. 

Of course, there may be a perfectly rational explanation in this case. We know, for instance, that Indian banks advise against using debit and credit cards in Nepal. So the minister may have been forced to carry all this cash and more since this was the amount found on him while he was about to take his return flight. It is also possible that the minister may not have known about the ban on Rs 500 and Rs 1,000 Indian notes in Nepal. But why didn’t anybody raise their eyebrows over the fact that somebody could be carrying Rs 9 lakh or even Rs 2 lakh in cash just like that?

Is it because money has got so devalued over time? No, that couldn’t possibly be the case because a majority of Indians continues to aspire to earn the mandated minimum wage for a skilled labourer, all of Rs 248 for an eight-hour workday in Delhi, which is denied to most workers in the unorganised sector.

Is it, then, because of growing corruption in high places involving increasingly larger sums of money? Even in the early 1990s, when the stock market trader Harshad Mehta claimed that he had paid Rs 1 crore in cash to the personal secretary of the then prime minister PV Narasimha Rao, people at large felt a bit let down by the modest sum. Not surprisingly, perhaps, because just a few years earlier, then prime minister Rajiv Gandhi had come under a cloud for 64 times that amount. The second half of the 1990s set a much higher benchmark when Bihar chief minister Lalu Prasad figured in a Rs 950 crore fodder scam. And now, of course, with Union telecom minister being repeatedly accused by the opposition parties of a 2G spectrum auction scam of anywhere between Rs 20,000 crore and Rs 1 lakh crore, the threshold has climbed much higher.

The home minister of a state of this country does not even bother to explain why he was carrying so much cash. He could be fighting hard in his own state to deal with the humungous problem of counterfeit currency, of the same denominations as he was carrying, flooding our economy, wait, wait, was that not the reason we leaned on Nepal to ban the notes in the first place?  Yet, the minister mumbles nonsense about not knowing the Nepal law (you really worry if he knows that is part of his job back home) and he is let off without explanation. It could all be perfectly legitimate cash, but there were times once upon, when a minister would have turned pink trying to explain this way because there would have been many more inconvenient questions asked.

It does seem that one of the weird aspects of "development" is the constant recalibration of our own shock meters. Unless each scam is bigger than the previous one we have no interest in it: ah, well, we've seen much worse, haven't we? Thus even as the aam aadmi or common man struggles to eke out a living, it is perhaps natural to get desensitised to somebody else’s money that defies comprehension in any case. The Nagaland home minister may well have carried several times the amount without anybody popping the once-natural question: But minister, minister, why were you carrying so much cash?

Comments

 

Other News

How corporates can nudge real change

The Business Of Business Is (Not) Just Business: How Behavioural Tools Can Drive Real Change Edited by Sutapa Banerjee, with Foreword by Nadir Godrej HarperCollins, 336 pages, Rs 699  

India stopped jailing people for paperwork. Now comes the hard part

A small pharmacist in Rajkot neglects to change a notice in his store under a little-known clause of a public health law. This was not only a non-compliance matter, but also a criminal offence, and a jail sentence was the punishment under the old system. Not a fine. Not a warning. Jail. Now scale

How to make our cities climate-resilient

Indian cities are growing at a pace that our infrastructure and climate can no longer sustain. This rapid urban sprawl increasingly strains urban systems, overshadowing the severe environmental fallout produced in its wake. The repercussions include Urban Heat Island Effect (UHI), Urban Floods, and many mo

Trump’s China setback pushes US to woo India

A week after Donald Trump’s visit to China – the first by an American president in nine years, US secretary of state Marco Rubio arrived in India on May 23 on a four-day visit aimed at resetting Washington DC’s relations with New Delhi and attending the third Quad ministerial meeting.

EU–India FTA 2026: A high‑stakes prescription for Indian pharma and healthcare

India’s pharmaceutical industry stands as one of the world’s market leaders of generic pharmacy with market valuation of USD 50 billion in 2026. Characterised by high volume, low-cost generic manufacturing, with an annual growth rate of 10-12% primarily propelled by exports and domestic demand,

Legends, vignettes and tales from the freedom movement

Robin Hood of Kathiawar and Other Extraordinary Stories from India’s Freedom Movement By The Paperclip  HarperCollins, 348 pages, Rs 499  





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter