Running out of ropemen

It's time to inject some modernity into the system

bikram

Bikram Vohra | June 3, 2011



A nation of over one billion people and not a hangman to slip the noose over death row’s Mahendra Nath Das, who has exhausted all his pleas and can only wait for the lumbering bureaucracy to find a trained hangman who can do the knot properly and according to custom.

This is no easy task and with executions becoming rarer the family business has died out with sons no longer ready to take over daddy’s business. The irony of a sliver of gallows humour in this impasse is not lost on any of us but there is something patently cruel about ordering a sentence by government that government cannot carry out. If the appointment with the executioner cannot be kept for a lack of proper personnel then the government has missed the date and must revisit this case, regardless of how heinous the crime.

No one has been hanged in Assam for 20 years. Only two people in India have been legally lynched in the past 15 years. Das is guilty of having decapitated his victim. The president has not agreed to clemency.
 
At a time like this it is also necessary to see into the validity of the killing process. If the country wishes to continue the option of capital punishment perhaps it is time for legislation to be passed that updates and modernises the options for legally taking a life.

Nowhere is it said that the Shylockian element of blood with the flesh is allowed. By sentencing someone to death in a procedure that takes years and becomes so far removed from the crime to make it almost obsolete as a tit for tat, neither suspense beyond the ordinary nor pain are inclusive codicils. Therefore, the law cannot accept a nation’s bureaucracy haring around looking for a volunteer. By this token, the agony of the death is not something that the law demands. Death per se is final enough. Consequently, it stands alone. Against this canvas perhaps India should move into the 21st century and think of lethal injections as a more humane way of killing a man or woman…at least there is no shortage of syringes.

Comments

 

Other News

What the US–Iran peace deal means for India

After months of rising tensions, the United States and Iran have reached a memorandum of understanding called the "Islamabad Agreement." This agreement allows for the immediate reopening of the Strait of Hormuz without tolls and provides Iran with relief from sanctions, depending on its complianc

V. M. Tarkunde: A legal luminary par excellence

14 Lawyers: Portraits from The Bar By Raju Ramachandran  Juggernaut, 248 pages, Rs. 799  

The Cost of Obesity

The latest episode of Checks and Balances focuses on the ticking time bomb of obesity in India, and Geetanjali Minhas of Governance Now spoke with a panel of experts. You can watch the episode here: https://youtu.be/mH

US-Iran deal: Path to peace or prelude to deeper regional quagmire?

In the midst of deep mistrust, the US and Iran are reported to have reached a framework deal for ending the West Asian conflict. But whether it will result in any meaningful breakthrough or pave the way for any lasting peace in the region, is in the realm of speculation.   During

Lived life, philosophy, spirituality and other enigmas

The Ashes Are Warm: Memories of a Lifetime Spent with UG Krishnamurti By Mahesh Bhatt and Sunita Pant Bansal Rupa Publications, 384 pages, Rs 495  

In Varanasi, fringe expansion vs. core heritage

For centuries, the urban framework of Varanasi was defined not just by its relationship with the sacred Ganga but by its multifaceted network of urban commons. Historic kunds, seasonal talabs (ponds), and open maidans served as the city’s basic ecological infrastructure. Th





Archives

Current Issue

Opinion

Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter