The irony of being Advani

He sowed the seeds, could not enjoys the fruits, now pays the price

ashishm

Ashish Mehta | April 19, 2017 | New Delhi


#Hindutva   #Babri Masjid   #Ram Janmabhumi   #Narendra Modi   #BJP   #LK Advani  


For a man who changed the destiny of the nation – not to mention the fortunes of his party, it is ironical that luck has ultimately not favoured him.

The ideology of Hindutva has been around since the early decades of the 20th century, but it was Advani which gave it political currency. Today, it has become the default ideology for the nation, but, as the Supreme Court puts him in the dock for conspiracy in the Babri demolition case, the man himself has nothing left but the loneliness of a futile long-distance runner in his last lap.

Read: LKA built BJP from bootstraps, remember?

For the BJP, hardline Hindutva was a necessity: the party had debuted in the Lok Sabha in 1984 with just two seats (in the aftermath of the Indira Gandhi assassination and the resulting sympathy wave for Rajiv Gandhi). The number rose to 84 in the next elections (in the aftermath of Rajiv losing popularity due to the Bofors scandal but also due to the Ram Janmabhumi campaign, which Advani, as the new party president, had launched).

In retrospect, the Ram Janmabhumi agitation, demanding construction of a temple in the spot claimed to be Lord Ram's birthplace – where the Babri mosque stood, seems like a God-given platform for Hindutva. It brought out the all the themes together – facts and myths of Islamic invaders who razed Hindu temples and the need for Hindu resurgence – with the emotional backdrop. No wonder, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad had been demanding it. But it was Advani’s acumen that made him and the BJP spearhead the movement and exploit its political potential.

Barring the JP movement of the mid-1970s, no other political campaign in independent India captured the imagination of the people the way the Advani-led Ram Janmabhumi movement did. And no other campaign was so carefully crafted. Eyewitnesses report that after the symbolically-rich Toyota rath yatra passed their village, many people in the Hindi heartland used to take a pinch of dust from the road and put it on their head. The slogan, 'Bachcha bachcha ram ka, janmabhoomi ke kam ka', had resonance among kids, and another one, 'Garv se kaho hum Hindu hain' was finally promising to bring Hindutva out of closet.

Between Vajpayee before him and Modi after, Advani has often candidly confessed that he is not the kind of orator who can move masses. But in those eventful days, he surprised himself by moving masses (leading to even riots in some places). Few political leaders have such a way with language as Advani, who coined the term ‘pseudo-secularism’. Is there any other term put to use in so many contexts, as reply to so many arguments, ironing out so many difficult nuances? Modi followers’ penchant for the term ‘nationalism’ is a reworking of Advani’s original.

The divisive agenda also served another purpose – of keeping the flock together against the onslaught of VP Singh’s social engineering during the battle of two ideologies that were shorthanded to Mandal and Kamandal.

For somebody who was to later discover secular virtues in Mohammed Ali Jinnah, one wonders if Advani was aware of the costs of his politics. But he did give political legitimacy to Hindutva and the BJP’s tally has rarely dipped afterwards.

That is why even when Vajpayee became the prime minister, many thought he was only a more acceptable mask and Advani was the one who really called the shots. In 2004, when the BJP surprisingly lost to the Congress, the prime ministerial candidate was Vajpayee, but in 2009, it should have been a walkover for Advani as prime ministerial candidate. Against a puppet-like Manmohan Singh, his projected himself as a decisive leader. And yet the Congress managed to beat anti-incumbency and achieved a rare feat in recent times – a second consecutive term.

That was when the luck turned against him, pushing him to the point where even a usually timid Manmohan Singh could tell a press conference that Advani needed to change his astrologer.

The final insult was to come from someone rightly or wrongly perceived as his protégé. Right when the Congress was ready to be defeated by whoever came first, Modi seized the mantle, won, and launched a new era of Hindutva, ending Advani’s era.

Read: Behind-the-door story of Advani's resignation

The curtains formally came when, replying to Advani’s graceful comment that the party would be grateful to Modi, he curtly said the veteran leader was wrong, and then went on to add platitudes of how he always considered the party was bigger than any individual.

Read:  Modi, Advani and mysterious symbolism of public gestures

Advani has been a lonely leader of late. Ironically, even the cause of Ram Janmabhumi which once put masses behind him won’t bring him out of his political vanvas today.
 

Comments

 

Other News

Parliament passes Citizenship amendment bill

The Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2019 has been cleared by parliament, as the Upper House on Wednesday passed the legislation that seeks to grant Indian citizenship to non-Muslims from three neighbouring countries. “A landmark day for India and our nation’s ethos of compassion an

Lok Sabha passes the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill

After a day-long debate which often turned acrimonious, the Lok Sabha has passed the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2019, seeking to provide citizenship to non-Muslims from three neighbouring countries who have migrated to India.   Prime minister Narendra Modi said he was “delighted&

Citizenship bill in Lok Sabha, triggers debate

Home minister Amit Shah on Monday introduced in the Lok Sabha the Citizenship Amendment Bill, triggering a long-ranging debate on the ideas of India, with the opposition parties claiming it was regressive. The bill seeks to grant citizenship to non-Muslim citizens of the neighbouring Pakista

Ambedkar home in Mumbai to become national monument

The chawl in Mumbai where Dr BR Ambedkar, the father of the Constitution, lived between 1912 and 1934 will be converted into a national monument. Maharashtra chief minister Uddhav Thackeray made the announcement on Friday, On the occasion of 63rd death anniversary of the visionary leader, af

Hyderabad rape and murder case: four accused killed in police encounter

Amid shock and outrage across the country over the rape and murder of a young woman in Hyderabad, the police on early Friday morning killed all the four accused in the case in Hyderabad. Police had taken the four to Chattapally, where they had allegedly burnt the woman’s body after rap



Archives

Current Issue

Video

CM Nitish’s convoy attacked in Buxar

Opinion

Facebook    Twitter    Google Plus    Linkedin    Subscribe Newsletter

Twitter