Unless SC stays it, Aadhaar law will prevail: Ravi Shankar Prasad -Governance Now

Unless SC stays it, Aadhaar law will prevail: Ravi Shankar Prasad

If a parliament enacts a law and unless the court stays the operation of the law, this law will hold the field, says minister

GN Bureau | April 10, 2017

#Aadhaar #Ravi Shankar Prasad #parliament #law #supreme court

Law and IT minister Ravi Shankar Prasad on Monday said that the interim orders of the supreme court on Aadhaar delivered in 2015 are meant for an "interim arrangement" and "it is not a judgement".

Responding to the questions in the Rajya Sabha, the minister said: "Some of our congress friends want to paint Aadhaar as the biggest tragedy of the country, and I disagree with them.”

He said that when the SC gave orders -- and the dates are August 11, 2015 and October 15, 2015 –“pervading a set of subsidies to be given directly, there was no Aadhaar law then. At that point in time the biggest argument in time in the court was that there is no statutory backing and you were taking biometrics of crore of people. And yes Jairam Ramesh you were wrong then. By executive order you can’t take so many biometrics. We needed a statutory enactment.”

He added that the second argument was privacy. “Because there is no executive order, there was no mechanism available. Now Sir, day in and day out I am asked a question in both houses why are you exceeding the judiciary….We are law making body. We are a sovereign body. We govern the country. We should seek accountability. Here is a case where parliament has done a robust law Aadhaar and it is completely robust. Legally speaking the law is well settled. That the parliament can remove the lacunae which the court points out.

The minister went on to say that the Aadhaar Act carried forward the whole architecture, “how whole biometric shall be done under what conditions, under what accountability. And whole architecture is available, it’s not the ecosystem, Jairam Ramesh”.

“If that is there, there is a law, there is no stay from the SC and we are being governed by the mandate of an Aadhaar Act, 2016, passed by the parliament. I stand by the sovereignty of the parliament for law making. Now whole of Aadhaar ecosystem is governed by law.

“And my understanding of law is very clear. That an interim order is only for the purpose of interim arrangement, till the parliament steps in. It is not a judgement. It has been referred to nine bench or seven bench. May be this law also be reconsidered. But I am clear that if a parliament enacts a law and unless the court stays the operation of the law, this law will hold the field.”

Comments

Other News

India stopped jailing people for paperwork. Now comes the hard part

A small pharmacist in Rajkot neglects to change a notice in his store under a little-known clause of a public health law. This was not only a non-compliance matter, but also a criminal offence, and a jail sentence was the punishment under the old system. Not a fine. Not a warning. Jail. Now scale

How to make our cities climate-resilient

Indian cities are growing at a pace that our infrastructure and climate can no longer sustain. This rapid urban sprawl increasingly strains urban systems, overshadowing the severe environmental fallout produced in its wake. The repercussions include Urban Heat Island Effect (UHI), Urban Floods, and many mo

Trump’s China setback pushes US to woo India

A week after Donald Trump’s visit to China – the first by an American president in nine years, US secretary of state Marco Rubio arrived in India on May 23 on a four-day visit aimed at resetting Washington DC’s relations with New Delhi and attending the third Quad ministerial meeting.

EU–India FTA 2026: A high‑stakes prescription for Indian pharma and healthcare

India’s pharmaceutical industry stands as one of the world’s market leaders of generic pharmacy with market valuation of USD 50 billion in 2026. Characterised by high volume, low-cost generic manufacturing, with an annual growth rate of 10-12% primarily propelled by exports and domestic demand,