Why you must spare a thought for this poor farmer... -Governance Now

Why you must spare a thought for this poor farmer...

...but not for the reasons given in this ad

SB Easwaran | December 3, 2016 | New Delhi

#gutkha #cigarette #FAIFA #all Indian farmers association #tobacco farmer #beedi

Why you must spare a thought for this poor farmer

Emotional appeal is one of the sharpest swords of advertising. That it is double-edged becomes evident only when it fails. One such failure is an ad from the Federation of All-India Farmer Associations (FAIFA), displayed of late on the rexine hoods of some auto-rickshaws in Delhi. It shows a turbaned tobacco farmer, hands folded in supplication, and is captioned: 'Protect our livelihood. Save lives of millions of tobacco farmers like me.' It asks the government to probe the hidden agenda of anti-tobacco campaigners and raises the bogey of foreign-funded NGOs.

This is bound to provoke sneers from a public familiar only with prosperous tobacco farmers and beedi, gutkha and cigarette magnates. Few will buy the insinuation that anti-tobacco groups highlighting the very real health risks of tobacco are the poor farmer's tormentors, working covertly for foreign tobacco companies. Angled wrong, the ad works against the doleful man in the picture. And raises the suspicion that the federation (established only in 2015) might be the creation of a group of rich tobacco farmers trying to wangle tax concessions.

On its website, FAIFA alleges that steep levies meant to deter tobacco consumption are encouraging the smuggling of foreign cigarettes, which are sold cheap and without the ugh-inducing pictorial warnings. This is not untrue. Figures from the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) indicate that 'butt-legging' has indeed skyrocketed. The picture might not be as bad as in Europe and along the US-Canada border, where big cigarette companies have been found to have links with smuggling mafias. But cheap contraband undermines government efforts to keep people healthier and robs it of revenue too.

Worldwide, science and sentiment have worked to deglamorise, if not effectively cut, tobacco use. But it's just a decades-old foray against a six-century-old addiction enmeshed in the history of mercantile, colonial and corporate power and profit. The small farmer who grows tobacco as a sturdy cash-crop in regions that will yield nothing else always was, and – as the ad, seen in sceptical light, reveals – still remains, a helpless coracle in these choppy seas, churned by immense merchant ships.

Policymakers and academicians vigorously debate the Millian question of how much the state may intervene to ensure healthy behaviour in citizens. The equally serious question of how to provide long-term livelihood alternatives to the farmer whose produce is losing acceptability for solid health reasons falls to activist groups. Sadly, some of these groups, though powerful enough to make themselves heard, are bogged in a crisis of credibility, thanks to their entanglement with vested interests. All the more tragic in a country where farmer suicides are a dark truth.

Comments

Other News

Caring for cancer patients: the expanded network of facilities

Health is a State subject, and the primary responsibility for providing healthcare services, including cancer care, rests with the respective state governments. However, the Department of Health and Family Welfare provides technical and financial support to States and Union Territories across the country

Capabilities, aspirations of India’s youth limitless: Modi

The capabilities and aspirations of India’s youth are limitless, prime minister Narendra Modi said in his remarks to the media at the start of monsoon session of the parliament on Monday. "In the past month, the country has achieved many milestones, filling citiz

India gets the first hydrogen train

Prime minister Narendra Modi on Friday laid the foundation stone and dedicated to the nation various development projects worth around ₹14,700 crore in Jind, Haryana. The PM positioned the city as a shining reflection of the good governance model. Emphasizing that the entire Haryana

Climate change is stealing sleep

Climate change has at least doubled the temperature-related sleep loss across 1,338 major cities worldwide over the past five decades, highlighting an emerging but often overlooked public health consequence of rising global temperatures. A new study by Climate Central estimates that between 2020 and

Cabinet approves Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme

The union cabinet chaired by PM Narendra Modi has approved the Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme (MPMS) with a budgetary outlay of Rs 62,500 crore. It aims to further scale up the production, deepen domestic value addition, strengthen supply chain resilience, enhance global competitiveness. It

Building infrastructure is only half the job

Recent stories of stolen railway wires, disappearing communication towers and missing public infrastructure are often treated as bizarre law-and-order failures of India. Yet they raise a more fundamental question. Why does the State often discover the disappearance of a public asset only after it has alrea